Independent Cape May hotels
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Top Cape May Hotel Reviews
Congress Hall
8/10 Good
"The check-in went fine until we tried to unlock our door. Our key did not work. I went to the front desk and after several attempts, new keys were cut to fit the lock. The staff is very nice and the poolside is comfortable with poolside food service. The alcoholic and non-alcoholic bar drinks were not the best at the hotel. There are several restaurants in the hotel and surrounding area. "
ICONA Cape May
10/10 Excellent
"Wonderful stay at this property in Cape May, NJ. We booked the premium king and had a great view of the ocean. We were on the 3rd floor. Rooms are tight but manageable and the bed is so comfortable. Lovely bathroom. We used the shuttle into town which was nice as parking is at a premium and we did not want to move our SUV and lose our spot. We had our own beach equipment (chairs and umbrellas) but ICONA provided this service free to the guests as well as the shuttle into town. Please tip. My only negative comments would be the coffee in the Keurigs...weak. And the pool. We could not use it as there were too many people in it and it was tiny. One great thing is Hemingways is next door and has happy hours from 12 to 6p every day and well worth it. We would stay at this property again. It was a lovely 4 days."
Grand Hotel of Cape May
10/10 Excellent
"Convenient with all the necessary amenities"
The Inn of Cape May
8/10 Good
"Everyone was very helpful and nice."
Coastal Estate
10/10 Excellent
"Everything was great! The beach, shopping, wineries, restaurants are all within 10 minutes away. Uber prices were high, but we also needed a vehicle for 5. We didn't use the kitchen amenities, but could be s great bonus to avoid dining out every meal. The pool area had nice cabanas and public bathroom, so you didn't have to walk back to your cottage. We didn't use the fire pit but the area was nice. I would love to stay again!"
The Cape
8/10 Good
"Fantastic location for visiting Cape May and the Coast guard academy. The price was a little steep for a dated motel. It was clean and check in with smooth and easy with a very helpful and pleasant clerk. The bed was quite soft for someone who is used to a black beauty, but what can you expect. I would go back and I would definitely recommend this hotel for someone looking to fill the basic need of a safe place to stay that is clean."
The Sandpiper Beach Club
10/10 Excellent
"We love it here! Perfect location and clean updated rooms. Highly recommend."
The Beach Shack
10/10 Excellent
"Clean, professional and not a bad view in the place ."
Oceanfront Oasis! Steps to the Beach! Hot Tub, Pool & Game Room!
10/10 Excellent
"We recently spent a weekend away at “Bayside Blessings,” and it was absolutely wonderful. The home was meticulously maintained and exceptionally clean. The kitchen was fully stocked with everything we needed, and both the pool and hot tub were fantastic. The game room was also a huge hit with both the kids and adults alike.The location was perfect, just a short walk to the beach and only minutes from downtown Cape May.And the views… absolutely amazing from nearly every room in the house.We enjoyed every second of our stay and truly cannot wait to return!"