Our daughter was getting married at the nearby San Moritz Lodge at Lake Gregory (which, by the way, is a great venue). We wanted a place reasonably close and large enough to accommodate last minute out-of-town guests if need be. This home worked great for us. It's 5-7 minutes from San Moritz, walking distance to Goodman's market, a 24/7 7-Eleven, and stumbling distance from the Bear Claw :) Granted, Crestline is a small town to begin with, but I found everything convenient. The outdoor deck would have been great for a family gathering after the wedding, but the weather was already too cold at night.
Yes, the layout is a little odd, but it didn't bother me. No wifi, but it wasn't listed as an amenity either. Even though it's fall, it would have been nice had the driveway and stairs been cleared of leaves, pine needles & acorns - I took care of it.
I hesitate in writing this, but...note on Goodman's, if you enjoy beers that you NEVER see in your big chain grocery store (or much anywhere else), be sure to stop in.