住宿地面
查看供應

米爾頓博南姆酒店的評價

3 out of 5
米爾頓博南姆酒店
Perth Road, Birnam, Perthshire, Dunkeld, Scotland

評價

8.2

很好

10 分評分，優異；155 則評價中有 60 則" "
8 分評分，不錯；155 則評價中有 61 則" "
6 分評分，一般；155 則評價中有 23 則" "
4 分評分，欠佳；155 則評價中有 5 則" "
2 分評分，很差；155 則評價中有 6 則" "

8.4/10 

整潔度

8.8/10 

職員與服務

7.0/10 

設施服務

7.0/10 

住宿狀況

7.6/10 

環保程度

評價

6/10 一般

Mark

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Nice hotel, plumbing might need fixing
The stay was absolutely grand up until a large leak in the corridor ceiling outside my room in the middle of the night. This created some hassle understandably. The dripping into buckets through the night made sleep quite difficult. Other than that, its an old building so makes noises naturally but this isnt too much of an issue
於 2024 年 1 月住了 2 晚
Jr 於 2024年1月18日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your review. We can only apologise for the water leak that occurred in the public corridor during your stay unfortunately this was as a result if the stormy weather at that time. We are please however that this did not put you off too much

8/10 不錯

Joan

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Warm welcome. Clean comfortable room, a bit dated, could do with decorating, however did not detract from a comfortable stay
於 2023 年 12 月住了 1 晚
Jr 於 2023年12月6日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your review

10/10 優異

Angela

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Cosy, simple 3 star B and B feel.
Have stayed before. Simple 3 star - homley feel, not grand but a great budget saver and lovely 10 minute walk from central Dunkeld and river. Lots of amenities near by.
於 2023 年 11 月住了 2 晚
Jr 於 2023年11月19日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

8/10 不錯

Romain

讚好：整潔度和住宿狀況
The architecture of this old building is amazing. However the breakfast is way too expensive and yet rudimentary. The dining room of the adjacent restaurant is ugly and freezing cold.
於 2023 年 10 月住了 1 晚
Jamed 於 2023年10月29日的回應
Thank you for you review, however we do take issue with your comment regarding the cost of breakfast which is competitively priced at 12.95 this equates to tea/coffee (2.75) toast butter, preserve 2.25) fruit juice 1.00) yoghurt (1.00) cereals (1.50) full cooked breakfast (7.50) 16.00. We are also very sorry that the decor of our restaurant was not your taste.

8/10 不錯

Jacqueline

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Overall good stay
It was good room, 3 beds, overall very good, breakfast fab. Shower not very powerful maybe because we were on top floor
於 2023 年 9 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2023年9月27日的回應
Thank you for your review

10/10 優異

Jean

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Staff was very welcoming . Hotel has lots of character.
於 2023 年 8 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2023年9月2日的回應
thank you for your review

8/10 不錯

Yves

於 2023 年 8 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年9月2日的回應
Thank you for your review

10/10 優異

Doherty

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Easy walk to all amenities very nice breakfast no slip mat's in shower
於 2023 年 8 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2023年8月27日的回應
Thank you for your kind review. We have addressed the Shower slip mat

10/10 優異

Malcolm

於 2023 年 8 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年8月27日的回應
Thank you for your positive review. We are pleased that you enjoyed you stay

10/10 優異

pernille

於 2023 年 8 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年8月27日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to complete your positive review

10/10 優異

Christine

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Lovely old building, rooms very roomy! Breakfast enormous and delicious! A hairdryer would have been great though! Staff friendly and obliging! Thank you for a first lovely night in Scotland!
於 2023 年 8 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年8月19日的回應
Thank you for your kind review. we are sorry about the hairdryer as there should be one in every room

10/10 優異

Gudrun

於 2023 年 8 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年8月17日的回應
Thank you for positive review

10/10 優異

peter

於 2023 年 7 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年8月2日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

8/10 不錯

Heather

於 2023 年 7 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年7月30日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

8/10 不錯

ALASTAIR

於 2023 年 7 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年7月19日的回應
Thank you for your review

8/10 不錯

Valona

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2023 年 7 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2023年7月16日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your review.

8/10 不錯

Colin

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2023 年 7 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年7月5日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

8/10 不錯

Neil

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2023 年 6 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年6月23日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

10/10 優異

Deborah

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Lovely old character building. Like walikng back in time. Little creaky, but what do you expect? No bar or evening restaurant, but plenty of local facilities to accommodate. Would definitely recommend and return.
於 2023 年 6 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年6月4日的回應
Thank you for your review. We do have a BAR and Restraunt which are located right next to the hotel unfortunately during these difficult staffing times and cost of living crisis we are unable to operate two bars, Kitchens and double staff. We are however pleased that you enjoyed your stay and we hope that we can welcome you back soometime in the near future

8/10 不錯

Loralyn

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Lots of character, beautiful high ceilings and large rooms.
於 2023 年 5 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年5月22日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your kind review

8/10 不錯

Sarah

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
We had a comfortable stay, it’s an old building and that is it’s charm. The staff was very helpful. The restaurant next door was also great.
於 2023 年 5 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2023年5月22日的回應
Thank you for your review

8/10 不錯

Kathryn

讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
Beautiful character, quiet. Pleasant outside walking track.
於 2023 年 5 月住了 1 晚
James 於 2023年5月22日的回應
Thank you for your review

8/10 不錯

Kimberley

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Lovely hotel with some original features. Lovely location, friendly staff
於 2023 年 4 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2023年4月25日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit a review on your recent stay with us. We are pleased you enjoyed your stay

4/10 欠佳

Donald

商務旅客
不滿：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
於 2022 年 10 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年10月29日的回應
Sorry we did not meet your expectations on this occassion

10/10 優異

Carley

家人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Excellent location, lovely friendly staff. Good size rooms, very clean, charming lift! Breakfast was lovely.
於 2022 年 10 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年10月29日的回應
Thank you for you review

10/10 優異

真實旅客

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2022 年 9 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年9月27日的回應
Thank you for your kind positive review

6/10 一般

James

讚好：職員與服務
Good value.
The hotel is visually impressive enough, but tired in various respects. Unfortunately, the key the key would not open the door to the first room we were allocated so we ended up in a smaller room nearby. Breakfast was substantial and very good and the food in the adjoining Birnam Inn was excellent. Overall probably quite good value for our 2 night stay.
於 2022 年 9 月住了 2 晚
jr 於 2022年9月21日的回應
Thank you for your comments we do really appologise that the first room was double locked by someone this as you are aware was rectified for the arrival of the rest of you party. We are delighted that you enjoyed your breakfast and the meals within our adjoining Birnam Inn

10/10 優異

William

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Our stay
Great stay, friendly cooperative staff
於 2022 年 8 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年8月12日的回應
Thank you so mush for your positive review

10/10 優異

Neil

於 2022 年 8 月住了 1 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和客房舒適度
Perthshire business stay
Did the job, comfortable bed, decent shower and good location for a conference at Birman arts. Nice walks to normal oak right behind hotel
於 2022 年 6 月住了 2 晚
jr 於 2022年8月6日的回應
We are pleased that we "did the job" that hat we are here for

10/10 優異

JACQUELINE

於 2022 年 7 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年8月1日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Excellent value
We had a brief overnight stay to attend a local wedding. The hotel was convenient had old Scottish charm & the beds were clean & comfortable. The decor is a bit dated but to be fair it didn’t matter as it was excellent value for money. We didn’t book breakfast as had an quick departure but they looked hearty.
於 2022 年 7 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年7月22日的回應
Thank you foir your kind positive review

6/10 一般

Dianne

多人同遊
讚好：職員與服務
不滿：住宿狀況
於 2022 年 7 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年7月4日的回應
Thank you for your review

6/10 一般

Kevin

讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
不滿：住宿狀況
Disappointing stay
Accomodatipn was ok but desperately needs updating to the present day. Bad repair on bathroom door which did not lock,paintwork drab, screw sticking out dangerously on curtain tieback and bare walls all add up to a 1980's throwback. Its a shame as the outside and main lobby are really nice but doesn't make up for the disappointing accomodation. Breakfast was ok but nothing special.
於 2022 年 7 月住了 1 晚
JR 於 2022年7月4日的回應
Sorry for your disappointing stay Ima afraid that this style of hotel is just not for you, however many of our guest sreturn year after year

8/10 不錯

Martin (Dunfermline)

家人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Just a one night stay, but would definitely come back again staff very friendly and helpful
於 2022 年 5 月住了 1 晚
James 於 2022年6月12日的回應
Thank you for your kind review

2/10 很差

Connie

伴侶同遊
不滿：職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Booked Monday and Tuesday - kitchen and bar closed - no food or drink. Returned on Tuesday afternoon. No housekeeping. Beds not made, towels not replaced and bin not emptied. Only saw one member of staff at any one time. Totally run down hotel!
於 2022 年 5 月住了 2 晚
jr 於 2022年6月12日的回應
sorry you were disappointed however all the point raised were intanated to you on arrival

10/10 優異

Catriona

於 2022 年 5 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年5月25日的回應
Thank you for your very positive review

10/10 優異

Jason (Lewisville)

伴侶同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Staff was extremely helpful
於 2022 年 5 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年5月25日的回應
Thank you for your kind review

10/10 優異

sheena

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Great time
於 2022 年 5 月住了 2 晚
jr 於 2022年5月7日的回應
Thank you for your positive review

10/10 優異

Steve

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和設施服務
This was just a 'stop over' for me en route. Now I wish it had been my 'destination'. Very comfortable and well fitted rooms yet embracing the 'old world charm' that I love when I visit castle hotels. Wish I had had more time. Thanks.
於 2022 年 4 月住了 1 晚
jr 於 2022年4月26日的回應
Thank you for your kind and positive review. We do hope that you will be able to stay with us again sometime soon

10/10 優異

Brian

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Could not fault but am hotel it was just fabulous the hotel itself was excellent the food very good the staff very friendly the room excellent will def go back
於 2022 年 4 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2022年4月12日的回應
Thank you for your kind review on your recent stay with us. We are delighted that you enjoyed your stay

10/10 優異

James

於 2022 年 3 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2022年4月1日的回應
Thank yolu for your positive review, we are pleased that you enjoyed your stay

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
Great location, basic hotel.
Good location in a lovely area. Room was basic and a little tired, but clean. The bed was comfortable, but just a basic double. It was difficult to reach the bath taps because the basin prevented the glass shower screen from being moved. No shower gel or shampoo provided, which I found a little mean for £90 per night B&B. The few staff (one person to handle reception and serve at the bar and restaurant) were friendly and helpful. Food was unexciting but reasonably priced, apart from several supplements on the breakfast menu.
於 2022 年 3 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2022年3月19日的回應
Thank you for your review. We are pleased that you enjoyed your stay with us. We appreciate your comments re staffing levels but this is not isolated to our business. With regard the supplement on the fish items on the breakfast menu we regrettably have had to charge a supplement on these items due to prices increasing by 50% from our supplier to us again this is not a situation exclusive to our business

6/10 一般

John

不滿：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Find another hotel
Terrible food, beer was bad and had to send it back. We did not get what we ordered. Basically everything is cooked from frozen probably bought out of a discount store
於 2021 年 12 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2022年1月4日的回應
We are please that you enjoyed your stay at the hotel, however are somewhat disappointed that you were not happy with your evening meal and drinks but can assure you that at no time do we serve meals from a discount store that being siad we can only apologise to you but if these comment and issues are not brought to our attention at the time it is very difficult to pin pount any downfalls that there might have been

10/10 優異

James

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2021 年 12 月住了 2 晚
james 於 2021年12月24日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to post you positive review

10/10 優異

Douglas

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Enjoyed our stay
We enjoyed our stay . It was during the virus and an almost lockdown conditions, so the hotel was very quiet , but very safe . We would like to return under normal circumstances . The hotel has plenty of character, which we love .
於 2021 年 12 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2021年12月20日的回應
Thankl you for taking the time to submit your kind review, We do hope that you will consider staying with us again in the future

10/10 優異

Jack

於 2021 年 12 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2021年12月14日的回應
Thank you for your kind review, We hope to ne able to welcome you back again soon

8/10 不錯

Marion

伴侶同遊, 多人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Warm, clean and comfortable on a cold, rainy evening. Lovely dinner in the Inn, prepared and served by friendly, pleasant staff. Disappointed that the bar wasn't open, though, to serve a nightcap drink at 10.00pm!
於 2021 年 11 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2021年11月27日的回應
Thank you for your positive review. unfortunately during these uncertain times we have to play each evening by ear and if staff are on duty and no customers for an hour or so then I am afraid for th viability of the business we have to take the unusual decision to close early. As on the night you stayed with us it was also a health and safety concern with regard the staff traveling home late at night during storm Arwen

10/10 優異

Paul

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2021 年 11 月住了 3 晚
james 於 2021年11月23日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your positive review.

10/10 優異

Robert

讚好：職員與服務
於 2021 年 11 月住了 1 晚
james 於 2021年11月18日的回應
Thank you for taking the time to submit your review, we are pleased that you enjoyed your stay with us