外觀
查看供應

星星酒店的評價

3.5 out of 5
星星酒店
7 New Wynd, Montrose, Scotland

評價

8.4

很好

10 分評分，優異；36 則評價中有 14 則" "
8 分評分，不錯；36 則評價中有 14 則" "
6 分評分，一般；36 則評價中有 6 則" "
4 分評分，欠佳；36 則評價中有 2 則" "
2 分評分，很差；36 則評價中有 0 則" "

8.2/10 

整潔度

8.4/10 

職員與服務

7.6/10 

設施服務

7.0/10 

住宿狀況

7.8/10 

環保程度

評價

10/10 優異

Sarah

於 2024 年 2 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

Jeff

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2023 年 10 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

Wendy

於 2023 年 9 月住了 1 晚

6/10 一般

真實旅客

多人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和客房舒適度
不滿：住宿狀況
Poor Quality Hotel
The hotel is very tired and needs a complete refurbishment. When I booked seven months in advance I had requested a room on the 2nd floor, partly as there is no lift, however our room allocated was on the 3rd floor with no option to change. At the time of our stay in August 2023 there is NO wifi available.
於 2023 年 8 月住了 3 晚

6/10 一般

mandy

家人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和設施服務
不滿：住宿狀況
3 flights of stairs, not good for disabled people. Fight in bar and please called. Police out again on next night. But breakfast was great.
於 2022 年 8 月住了 2 晚

10/10 優異

jonathan

於 2022 年 4 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

David

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Friendly staff, good location, reasonably priced. Tasty breakfast
於 2022 年 3 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

Martyn

於 2022 年 3 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

Wendy

家人同遊, 寵物同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
It was very local to all amenties , friendly and very welcoming and very nice breakfast.
於 2021 年 11 月住了 2 晚

10/10 優異

Jason

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Thanks great
於 2021 年 11 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

John

商務旅客
讚好：職員與服務
於 2021 年 11 月住了 3 晚

6/10 一般

Catherine

商務旅客
讚好：職員與服務
於 2021 年 10 月住了 2 晚

8/10 不錯

David

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和客房舒適度
Good value for money.
The accommodation was good value for money. A typical mid town old hotel with a bar underneath. Bed was comfortable. We were promised on site parking but there are only 2 spaces. We had to park down the road in the Argos carpark and only free for 2 hours after 8.00am so had to be out by 10.00. Breakfast was okay/good.
於 2021 年 8 月住了 1 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Close to everything and very friendly
於 2021 年 6 月住了 4 晚

4/10 欠佳

真實旅客

家人同遊
不滿：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Liked:clean bed linen, clean ensuite Disliked:public bar entrance on arrival, no Reception Area, 3 floors to climb after 7 hr journey, smelly, nicotine infused stair carpets (probably from pre-smoking ban), 2 disturbed nights: one through noisy neighbour (thin walls) and second through fire alarm at 4am- we stood outside for about 20 mins, in nightwear. In-room Wi-Fi did not work, Breakfast was limited with no filter coffee, cereals, fruit.
於 2021 年 6 月住了 2 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
OK minus
Central but old. No lift, but great exercise walking up 4 stairs. Good internet reception. Newly renovated bathroom. The bed could have been more comfy. I felt the springs through the mattress. You can park right outside the hotel but the staff does not recommend it because of the hotel bar is there. Park at your own risk, even though it is on their property.
於 2020 年 8 月住了 3 晚
Star Hotel 於 2020年9月1日的回應
Thank you for your review. We appreciate the time guests take to do this and it gives us an opportunity to address any issues that we may be unaware of. We have now changed the mattress in the room you were in and I have spoken to the staff member that checked you in, this information regarding parking only related to Saturday nights when previously would be very busy in the bar area. In the current climate this is not the case and should not have been told to you - I did go to your room to explain this and that you were fine to park outside. I apologise for the confusion caused.

8/10 不錯

Paul

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
enjoyed
Staying for work in montrose and certainly one of tghe better hotels. Staff lovely and friendly. Would come again.
於 2020 年 3 月住了 4 晚

8/10 不錯

James

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和住宿狀況
Very Enjoyable
I enjoyed my stay at the Star Hotel. The staff were great and 'Dave' carried my 22 kilo bag all the way to the top floor (3 flights, I was only able to help on the first one). Being that the tap water is labeled as Not for Drinking. I think a 1 to 1-1/2 liter bottle should be included with the room. The small bottle hardly leaves enough for a drink at night, coffee in the morning and still be able to get the blood pressure pills down :) But I do recommend the Star. I wish I still drank alcohol. I would have enjoyed some good local brew.
於 2019 年 11 月住了 4 晚

8/10 不錯

Davy

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2019 年 9 月住了 1 晚

6/10 一般

Henry

不滿：住宿狀況
You have to go through the bar to sing in, in my case I was regersted and given my kyes in the bar. Some of my detales are private and I dont think it is profentual to shair them in a public bar
於 2019 年 8 月住了 4 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

商務旅客
讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
I liked it here, owners were nice and welcoming on arrival, the bar staff were also a good bunch. The area is like a stereotypical coastal town including hundreds of VERY noisy seagulls so make sure you pack some ear plugs, they’re a MUST. Breakfast room was great, could do with a tv on in the background for me. Good value breakfast. Good value everything really.
於 2019 年 8 月住了 3 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

家人同遊
讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、設施服務和住宿狀況
Jag älskade de nyrenoverade rymliga fräscha toaletterna/dusch. Sköna sängar och bra kuddar. Det är en mindre rörelse med familjär stämning. Vänlig och hjälpsam personal. Centralt beläget.
於 2019 年 8 月住了 5 晚

8/10 不錯

Keith

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務和客房舒適度
Quaint and good value
We found the Star (one of the oldest coaching inns left in Scotland we were told), was absolutely fine for a couple of nights and Montrose is a small but quaint town, with a few things to do over a short stay. The Star hotel is also a pub and one should not be put off by the check-in being in the bar, where you are likely to walk past a few regular local characters. Our room was on the 3rd floor and there is no lift, but David the owner very helpfully carried our case all the way up. The owners are trying to sell up, but the standards are fine, albeit the decor and furnishings need updating. Would we go there again for a short stay - yes we would, so that says it all.
於 2019 年 5 月住了 2 晚

8/10 不錯

真實旅客

讚好：整潔度和職員與服務
Lovely rooms,helpful staff , however communal areas tired looking
於 2019 年 5 月住了 1 晚

4/10 欠佳

Martin

不滿：住宿狀況
於 2019 年 1 月住了 1 晚

8/10 不錯

Phillip

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Clean spacious room
First impressions was that it was run down and in need of some renovation but once showed to my room it was obvious that some money had been spent. The room was very spacious with a large bed and nice bathroom with a good shower which is very important for me. The owners are very friendly and helpful. Parking is limited but you can park for free about 20 yards away. Breakfast was good and cooked fresh to your liking.
於 2018 年 11 月住了 4 晚

6/10 一般

真實旅客

讚好：職員與服務
不滿：住宿狀況
Old hotel needing some work
It was not so good as pictures , staff was lovely but hotel is very old and run down
於 2018 年 9 月住了 2 晚

8/10 不錯

Sue

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
於 2018 年 8 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

Amy

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Great little place to stay!
The ladies who checked us in and showed us to our room were both extremely nice. The room looked recently renovated and the bathroom was spacious and was very clean. The room was a good size for two people. The booklet of information was very helpful and the free water and tea pot was convenient. Cozy!
於 2018 年 8 月住了 1 晚

10/10 優異

真實旅客

讚好：整潔度、職員與服務、住宿狀況和客房舒適度
Easy check in and check out, friendly staff and clean, comfy room
於 2018 年 3 月住了 1 晚

8/10 不錯

Joe

讚好：職員與服務
So So
Needs a lot of TLC, friendly staff, car parking a issue, overpriced not including breakfast
於 2018 年 2 月住了 1 晚