Beach Haven Shelter Island Hotels

"The location of this property was perfection. We rented for a few days over New Years with some friends and their kids. The bunk rooms were perfect for the kid! Although it was winter we all said this house couldn’t be more perfect for the warm weather. With the basement, location to Fantasy Island and the beach and the pool, you couldn’t ask for more. The host was very responsive too!!! We all had a great time in this rental!!"

"Clean room"

"The house is such a lovely house with seven bedrooms. We stayed there for the weekend after Christmas. Extended family joined us in memory of my parents/their grandparents/etc. The family and dining room aren’t super big so a little cozy if you’re spending a lot of time inside. Nice outside eating area that I’d have loved to take advantage of in warmer weather. Kelly was very responsive and helpful. The beds were comfortable. "

"Location was awesome!!!"

"Booked this for our family and wedding party—-it was a perfect house for a big group. Great location, beautiful home with lots of charm and wonderful hosts. Would definitely recommend!"

"This beach cottage was perfect for my dog and I while we were in Beach Haven for my daughter's wedding weekend. The location was central to everything and within easy walking distance to all Beach Haven has to offer. The people who stayed in the front house couldn't have been nicer and our dogs all got along and shared the common fenced in backyard, which was terrific for my dog. Also great neighborhood for walks. "

"Perfect house for us and our dogs. Fenced in backyard and close access to everything."

"The perfect beach house in a great location. Well appointed with everything we could need for our weekend getaway. Super"

"Great trip comfortable beds."