City Island Beach Holidays

The only place my fiance and I stay in New York! Amazing staff, great rooms, reasonable price and perfect location.

The property is beautiful and in a perfect location! We will be back.

Room was clean, the staff wonderful. We didn't access the full amenities of the hotel as we were busy enjoying broadway (1-2 blocks away, if that), shopping, and walking. Property is half a block from Time Square. You are in the heart of the fun, the vibration of the city. Sometimes the noise from Time Square expands past the square and it can be a little distracting, so I would request a non-street room. Honestly, a classy hotel where they get to know their guests and they greet you as you come and go. Awesome.

The staff that we encountered were all professional and personable. We had an excellent view of the Empire State Building and the city overall and found the hotel's location to be very convienient to the proximity of our intended activities and to Penn Station for our departure and arrival. The hotel was clean, felt safe, and I would definitely stay there again. A few things to note are as follows: 1. There are only 3 elevators for the hotel so factor the wait time into any plans that you may have. 2. The closet space is very minimal and there is only one drawer for clothing, so if you have multiple people in the room you can count on living out of your suitcases. 3. There are not many hooks, towel bars, or places for your own tolietries within the shower space. 4. The shower door opens towards the toliet, so it can be a bit awkward to navigate with multiple people using one bathroom. 5. The breakfast set-up is not ideal at all. The corridor to enter and exit the hallway is very narrow and it feels like getting on an off the train during rush hour. There is nowhere to wait outside of the tables and chairs for eating, so that can be a bit chaotic even if you decided to take food back to your room.

The property is beautiful and in a perfect location! We will be back.

10/10 on everything!