Mackinac Island Hotel with Pool

"Beds were comfortable, breakfast was average, and the location was amazing. Lower rating because it was run down in some ways-wallpaper in our room had scratched like furniture had been dragged down the wall, some corners in the bathroom weren’t clean, and the sliding door track stuck a little. Nothing devastating, but not what I expected for their top tier suites. We got in late and it was snowing in the morning so we asked if could check out an hour later and were told no. I didn’t understand why because it’s a weekday in the offseason. They were nowhere near full and it would have been a good chance for great customer service."

"Water park is fun."

"Was stuck in a blizzard and the staff was great trying to keep the kitchen open and everything running while they were dealing with limited staffing and weather challenges, which drove more than the average customers during this. Period."

"Helpful staff!!"

"We stayed in mid October 2025 and would definitely go back. "