We had 15 people of all ages and needs stay. We had a fabulous time, and the property was ideal.
At the same time, I can see why a few people who left reviews were disappointed. So I thought I'd offer a few comments:
Pros:
- Ideal for hosting a large group comfortably
- Everything as advertised, clean and functional
- Well-stocked with necessaries (utensil, towels, etc.)
- The hosts are super responsive and helpful, without being intrusive
- The pool is amazing - warm, spacious and very usable
- Ability to bring a pet (in this case a well-trained comfort dog) was key for our group
- Layout is excellent for people with limited mobility
- Location is phenomenal - beautiful sunsets, great walks, convenient to SD attractions
Cons:
- There is a long list of rules, relative to most rentals I've stayed at, which is somewhat intimidating. We had no issues, but it's something to be aware of
- This is an older house that was built up through additions. It has some quirks. If you're looking for a brand-new McMansion style, this isn't it. There were some spots with wear-and-tear, though nothing that affected our stay.
- Several of the sleeping slots are sleeper-sofas in the living room, or extra-beds/pullouts in some of the bedrooms. This is all as-advertised, but does require some piling-in together to achieve the max capacity. We ended up renting the casita (extra $$$, again as-advertised) so that we could keep the living room free for socializing. So, pay close attention to the roster of sleeping areas, etc.
Again, it was great for us, very comfortable, and should work really well for any large group. However, for a smaller group, or if looking for "pristine" / "new construction" type feel, you may want to look elsewhere.