Independent Caroga Lake hotels

"Great. 2nd time we've stayed there. Got a great suggestion on a local restaurant. Rustic bar & grill"

"Room was clean and nice. "

" My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed our three nights stay at the Stone Mill Inn. At first, the heat in the room was not working. Dominic moved us to a much nicer room with heat late at night. I was very thankful as was my wife. We had a great time. We will return in spring."

"Incredible property."

"The room was sparkling clean and welcoming. We loved the comfortable mattress and the luxurious bedding. Thank you for this lovely retreat just where we needed to find an overnight stay. Safe and comfortable! "

"The farm animals and the caboose were amazing "

"Big bed"

"I was traveling and decided to stay at the Hotel Broadalbin. It is a nicely restored 170+ yr old hotel with restaurant/bar on the main street in a small village. Had a nice chat with the owner. It has the feel of stepping back in time. All the rooms were restored a few years ago and have that 19th century feel, antique furniture, etc. The bed was comfortable. I liked the smart Roku TV. I stayed there again the following week when i came back through. So much nicer than any of the chain hotels. "

"Wonderful hotel. Welcoming staff and they had warm chocolate chip cookies at check in, coffee and tea in the guest breakfast area 24/7. The room was spotless and the beds very comfortable. Great value and I highly recommend if in Johnstown, NY"