Plymouth Mayflower Society House Hotels

"Friendly, helpful staff"

"We have stayed here many times after getting married here in 2020. The splash pad and pool is perfect for our 2 young children. This last stay was probably our least favorite stay. The hotel is under major renovations which we didn't know about until we arrived. During our stay there was a dryer lint fire that filled the hotel with heavy smoke. my family and I were napping on the 4th floor where the smoke detectors failed to sound. We only got out of the building cause I awoke to the smell of smoke. Checked the hallway and saw the emergency lights flashing but no alarm sounding. Called the front desk no answer then looked outside to find several fire trucks and first responders. I woke up my family and we ran down the stairs as the fire fighters were running up them. very scary to stay somewhere that had malfunctioning fire alarms especially somewhere we love to return to. If the fire had not been contained we could have had a very serious situation. Will never stay anywhere unless we are on the 1st floor after this experience."

"Room was clean. Did not care for sliding door to bathroom which was jamming up and very hard to open/close and very loud. Not to mention offers no privacy with little kids who open the door since it can't be locked. My 2 yr son would not stay out of the bathroom, not safe for toddlers. We originally were staying at hotel 1620 r9r the pool and splash pad/slides which had a fire. We then got a room at the John Carver for the pool with water slide which slide was not open the first day as no lifeguard was on duty with a pool full of kids. Very disappointing as that is why we choose this hotel instead of calling our trip short and going home. hotel is under renovations so it was extremely noisy during our stay from loud banging and buzzing due to using machinery for the remodel."

"The place was wonderful with windows that opened for fresh air. The bed was more comfortable than our own and the bedding was fresh and beautiful. We would stay there again in a heart-beat if we're ever again in Plymouth. "

"Clean, friendly and good breakfast"

"The condo/apartment was as advertise, we enjoyed our stay very much, it's in a great location!"

"The Hotel is older however it has gone through a wonderful update. I stayed there April 23,2026-April 26.! The decor in my room was modern with a very clean look. The Hotel interior has a beach look and was updated nicely. The workers, especially the front desk check in were kind, helpful and all around accommodating . Breakfast was good and the view-of the ocean was a plus. Heads up there is no elevator."

"Location Location Location!!!"

"Perfect!"