McFarland Hotel with Pool

"The hot tub was luke warm at best. The breakfast was okay but there were not a lot of healthy options. Overall the clientele of this hotel were very sketchy. Smelling marajuna in the parking lot was a clear indication that this is a party hotel. The pool and hot tub were very busy with young families and did not feel like a comfortable place to relax. The staff was friendly but I would not chose to stay in this hotel in the future. "

"The breakfast was amazing along with the service. Had drinks in the bar and bartenders were great.Room was clean, comfortable and quiet."

"Great location. Onsite parking was a plus"

"Nice bartender "

"The property is meticulously maintained and beautiful. The staff is informative, helpful, and kind. The pillows are heavenly. It was a very enjoyable stay."

"Breakfast is better than average. Location is very convenient to UW campus (especially Lakeshore area). Facilities could use more upkeep."

"We will never be returning to the Edgewater. We had some bad customer service. The car shuttle service was excellent, and the valet staff was friendly and nice. However, the front desk and the general manager failed us. When I called requesting housekeeping, the staff member had a language barrier and didn’t follow through on getting someone to come clean our room. We went two days without housekeeping despite multiple requests. I also asked twice to have the sheets and linens changed, and no one ever showed up. I ended up waking up with a rash on my face from the dirty bedding,. When we returned to our room, towels were everywhere and the garbage was overflowing. The manager showed up seeming like he had a stick up his a**, he was distasteful, dismissive, defensive and accusatory, he seemed offended that we’d ask for fair compensation for a bad experience on our wedding night. The front desk’s failure to follow through and the manager’s hostile attitude really ruined what should have been a memorable experience. 2/10 definitely not recommended."

"The first room we checked into had food in the freezer and the toilet wasn't working. The second room had a working toilet and was cleaner, but I don't know why I paid $20 more for a "king suite with separate seating area" as it was one room. It looked like the pictures on the website for the "studio king room." The pool was fun, but hadn't been cleaned overnight. There was foam from someone's pool toy all over the pool deck and in the pool. Finally we went to breakfast, and all of the empty tables were dirty. The food bins were empty, and the worker was just playing on her phone. She came out when I asked her if she could refill the trays, but she had to go and start heating the frozen food. We gave up and went out for breakfast. On a positive note, the room was quiet!"

"My stay was great! Definitely a new favorite hotel!"