Top Vacation Homes in Rum Cay in 2026

Check prices for these dates

In two weeks

In two months

In three months

In four months

Our top choices for Rum Cay holiday homes

A wooden deck with a view of turquoise waters and a distant shoreline.

1. Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

Cutlass Bay

Emily C.

A beach view from a covered area with a wooden ceiling and palm trees.

2. The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

Cat Island

Debra M.

A pool area with a clear view of the sea, surrounded by palm trees and lounge chairs.

3. The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

Cat Island

udreauAmanda B.

A wooden interior with large windows overlooking a beach. There are wicker chairs and a bamboo bench.

4. Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

Cat Island

Elizabeth R.

A balcony with a view of a sandy beach, palm trees, and the ocean under a partly cloudy sky.

5. On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

Thompson Bay (Salt Pond)

LORRAINE S.

A wooden deck leading to a white building with a balcony, surrounded by lush greenery.

6. White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa

Port Howe, Greenwood

"The view from this location is stunning and the beach is beautiful. A few things I wish we would have know before we went: 1. When we got to the house their was no fresh water. Be sure you pick up a 5 gallon jug of water before you come to the home. 2. Due to high rains the roads were flooded so it took as quite a while to get to and from the grocery store. The location is remote so you don't want to have a flat tire. Be careful of the potholes. 3. A.J.'s convenience is closer than Gilberts...

Jetsy B.

A wooden deck with a view of the beach and sunset.

7. Bahamas oceanfront paradise. 250 off if you stay 8 nights.

San salvador

Lynn B.

A clear view of a beach through a natural rock arch, with turquoise water and a sandy shore visible.

8. Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.

Salt Pond

John I.

View all properties

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Apartments

Condos

Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in

Sign in

Sign up, it's free

Top Rum Cay Hotel Reviews

Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

10/10 Excellent

"Wonderful experience, highly recommend"

Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

10/10 Excellent

"This property was amazing. Just as it was advertised. The house manager was awesome and very prompt with answering all text and issues. The home was very clean and spacious. My family of 6 had a great time with our feeling in top if each other. Sometimes, the power would go out but there is a generator on site. We love all the toys and games on site ads all. Thank you so much for an amazing time. We will definitely book again the next time we travel to Cat Island."

On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

8/10 Good

"The house is a duplex, but before our stay I asked the host, Cathy, if anyone would be staying in the other unit. She assured us it would be vacant, so we had the entire property to ourselves, which made it feel incredibly private and peaceful.The beach is a bit rocky, so we didn’t swim there, but the pool more than made up for it. It was much bigger than it looked in the photos and was perfect for relaxing.My only complaint was the Wi-Fi. It relied on a single hotspot, and since we needed to answer emails and download files, the connection was very slow and made it difficult to get work done.Other than that, everything was wonderful. Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with us. We made unforgettable memories that will stay with our family forever."

Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

10/10 Excellent

"This property met and exceeded our expectations. The central location made it easy to explore both north and south. An easy drive to either airport. Groceries, liquor and gas right around the corner. We spent every evening relaxing at the water’s edge watching the wildlife, distant lightning and stargazing. Lots of turtles, a leopard ray, dolphins and tons of fish right in front of the cottage! Debbie and Phil are fantastic hosts! We can’t wait to come back later this year!"

The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

10/10 Excellent

"We loved every minute of our mini vacation. The house and property were outstanding. The owner, Stephanie was amazing with her communication and travel information. Highlights of our short visit were the Healing Hole and the Hawks Nest Marina. The property was one of a kind with its own kayak marina and snorkeling cove. The house and property were the best. We loved swimming in the pool that overlooks this amazing view. The crystal clear water views from the porch was something we will always remember. The best was the sound of the ocean and the lights from the stars at night. This is truly a very special vacation spot that we would highly recommend. Thank you Stephanie and care taker Harrison."

New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

10/10 Excellent

"Our stay in Long Island, Bahamas was absolutely fantastic! Erik was an exceptional host who communicated with us every step of the way, making the entire experience seamless. Karin, the house manager, met us at the airport and guided us to the house, which was a wonderful personal touch. Mr. Percy also provided excellent communication and had a great rental car waiting for us when we arrived.The house exceeded our expectations. It was beautifully equipped with everything we needed, especially the spacious kitchen, which had every item imaginable for preparing meals. The infinity pool was incredible, the beds were very comfortable, and the home was the perfect place to relax after exploring the island.A special thank you to Zoe from Long Island Boat Rentals, who made boating effortless by delivering our boat directly to the house and securing it to the mooring ball behind the property. We spent our days discovering the island's stunning beaches by both car and boat.We especially enjoyed dining at Tiny's Restaurant, found an excellent fresh fish market near Clarence Town, and highly recommend visiting Mr. Watson at Gordon's Restaurant on the southern tip of the island for the breathtaking views alone.This was truly an unforgettable vacation, and we wouldn't hesitate to rent from Erik again. We had an amazing time and can't wait to return!"

Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

10/10 Excellent

"For two of us, this property was perfect! It’s designed for 2 couples or small family with 1 & 1/2 bath. I wouldn’t want to share but you easily could. Nothing fancy but perfectly adequate. Good A/C, loved the clothesline and even better, the many hooks inside the house. Easy access to swimming and snorkeling in Cutlass Bay, some shade coverage on deck and terrace near beach. Friends rented The Point House which offered a pool, so it’s a good combo to rent if larger party. Same with Gate House but we didn’t go into that house. Kayaks are fun to use tooCat Island is a laid back, non-touristy island. It forces you to relax. Activities other than swimming, relaxing and light snorkeling are hard to come by. While we didn’t participate, Greenwood has dive and snorkeling trips. So if low activity isn’t your jam, then Cat Island may not be for you. We found it perfect with incredibly friendly people, all extremely helpful and sharing. Do your research on where to eat and you’ll eat well. From this property, on the weekend, you can walk to Da Pink Chicken (recommend!) but need to drive for other dining experiences. We loved Hidden Treasures and Greenwood Beach Club, but it’s wise to call ahead to be sure they are open. Da Smoke Pot was a fun Rake and Scrape experience too. And Olive’s bakery has delicious bread, especially coconut and cinnamon.The New Bight Airport and much welcomed road paving in southern part of island should be done by end of 2026."

Find out more about Rum Cay

Rum Cay Vacation Homes information

Number of reviews	224
Accommodation	16 Vacation Homes
Lowest Price
Highest Price

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Our top choices for Rum Cay holiday homes

1. Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

2. The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

3. The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

4. Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

5. On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

6. White Ocean Coral - Private Beach Villa

7. Bahamas oceanfront paradise. 250 off if you stay 8 nights.

8. Beachfront family home steps from the perfect secluded ocean beach.

9. New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

10. Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

11. On the beach, Private path to the ocean beach.

12. Ocean View Coral - Private Beach Resort

13. Modern Beautiful 3-bedroom house in Bennetts harbor, Cat Island

14. Snow Bay Villa, San Salvador

15. SHE SHACK for Solo Female on Fabulous Long Island

16. Located in Greenwood Estates, Port Howe on Cat Island. Battery backup system!!

Find holiday rentals that suit your style

Top Rum Cay Hotel Reviews

Cat Island Paradise . Overlooking turquoise waters and sky, sunrise and sunset.

Spectacular Ocean Front Home with a Beautiful Secluded Sandy Beach.

On The Beach ~ House Marlin, with Pool!

Private Beautiful Cottage with your own cove

The Point House Luxury 5 bedroom Oceanfront Villa with Cliffside Pool, Kayaks

New Private Pool, Private Beach and Flat, Private House, what else do you need?

The Gatehouse – Ultra-Private Oceanfront Villa + Pool + Starlink WiFi + Kayaks

Banana Wind Oceanfront Home ~ Private Beach, Snorkeling, Kayaks, Stunning Views

Stella Maris Resort Club

Find out more about Rum Cay

Rum Cay Vacation Homes information