Pros: kitchen feels premium; living room is very nice with large smart TV; 2 bedrooms downstairs and bathroom are very comfortable; towels and linens are included; good amount of space throughout; host Marissa is incredibly responsive; short walk to beaches; has parking for 3+ vehicles; very clean overall.
Cons: the upstairs masters bathroom does not have a shower, only bath tub - and the tub is actually in the bedroom itself, not the bathroom. OK for us, since we're a couple but others may need to think about this. Also physically difficult to get in and out of tub safely, because of the way it's positioned - had to hold on to a towel bar for fear of slipping. Nowhere to hang clothes in masters bedroom.
Overall, we had a great stay. One note about location - this is far away from the more commercial part of the Outer Banks (Kitty Hawk, Kill Devil Hills, Nags Head) so if it's your first time in the OBX, you may spending a lot of time driving. Few restaurants in the area, but then again, the house has a great kitchen.