Montello Buffalo Lake Hotels

"Good stay! "

"Positives : We went during the off season and the hotel was pretty much to ourselves same with the water park and arcade. Which was perfect for us and our 1 year old . The room has a whirpool which was also a plus , very spacious for the little one to wander . The waterpark was definitely run down and paint chipping . Water was cold besides the hot tub. You can tell that at some point this hotel was in its prime but in 2026 definitely needs some work done and lots of maintenance. A lot of the amenities did not work- our tv and remote were not working , laundry was not working , we had to plug the fridge and microwave in ourselves . Overall we did enjoy it mostly because we got all the space to ourselves . "

"Restaurant hours are sporadic and not always available, for that reason we never had breakfast at the restaurant. Restaurant was open for dinner 2 of the 4 nights we were there. We did have dinner Monday night and the dinner was pretty good. "

"Not many breakfast options "

"COCKROACHS. DON’T stay here!!!! Tell other families not to. This place is a disaster. Building 10 cockroach infestation. I emailed a picture of the cockroach to management and requested a refund. Checked out early and hotel management asked me to sign a corrupt agreement that says customer won’t disclose.l in exchange for a refund that was equivalent to one night stay and a credit to come back to this cockroach party. I disputed the charge to my credit card company and will file a complaint to state health department inspections and appeals, hotel licensure, better business bureau, and the WI Attorney General’s Office. Mt. Olympus knowingly exposes families to health risks associated with cockroach infestations. "

"I loved the stay, they offer everything that they have with the room, they was very clean, and the staff was friendly and helpful. I will definitely be back. "

"If you'd like a quiet, clean, friendly place with a retro vibe, this place is exactly what you need. My daughter wanted to avoid the water parks so we chose this place and I'm so glad we did. They were so helpful and nice. Our room was big and had exactly what we needed. The retro vibe started with the retro hotel key chain and continued on in the room. It was a very clean, nice stay. I'd recommend it to anyone if they dont want to be in the water park hotels. It was located in the downtown area and super convenient to everything."

"We absolutely loved staying here. Our kids and family had a blast and we did not even need to leave the room much. It was comfortable and homey. Great communication and cleanliness overall. Would absolutely book this again. "

"Rustic. Quiet. Clean."