For the price, it's difficult to find a comparable hotel in NJ. But there are tradeoffs. It's not really near anything other than Delicious Orchards and the local horse and golf attractions. So it's nice and safe, but also not many and only local stores and food places. A good rural selection, but 20+ minutes curvy driving for fast food or groceries. I think it's the farthest you can get from a chain restaurant in NJ.
The staff is the right balance of helpful and disinterested, at least for me. This means they may forget an issue, but also aren't going to hassle you. The rooms are tidy and well cleaned. Because the building is historic, many items are not upgraded. This is great for beautiful vintage bathrooms, bad for windows that don't really close or frighteningly patched ceilings. Bugs from outside (ants, carpenter ants, spiders, beetles, ladybugs) will easily get inside, but it's more because of the outdoorsy location and old building. No biting bugs or other pests seen over several summer stays.
Rt 34 can be loud. Nothing to do. It's a fire response route, so at least one calamitous siren affair a day. But the only noises you'll hear from within the hotel are other doors opening and closing.
Breakfast is continental. It's just fine, though they need new/additional toasters. Coffee, yogurt, bagels, cereal, apples. The breakfast room is cute and available for recreation. Gorgeous lobby, with coffee, cookies, lollipops. But the well water needs treatment!