Carling Lally Island Hotels

"Nice, relatively new property. Very clean. Nice hot and cold breakfast buffet options."

"Room was great!!! Staff were nice!!! It would of been nice if the hot tub was working… "

"Rooms are dated but comfortable "

"Good"

"All the above "

"Room was spotless and bed was good. Coffee in room was pretty bad and no shampoo, but over-all, delightful. "

"Front Desk Staff were Amazing but the hotel was as definitely lower quality than the price tag. We rented the jacuzzi room for Valentine’s Day for $225 and the tub was whole reason we were there. The room was not just dated, it was pretty grubby and dingy. The indoor pool was a nice surprise. But lack of basic amenities like ice, vending, sufficient towels in the room ( there were only 2 towels in the room despite the jacuzzi tub and No towels poolside) was a bit shocking. Long hairs in the shower upon arrival, mattress cover coffee stained, bed sheets with multiple sharpied “K” along all edges of the sheets to identify them as King size, chunks of popcorn ceiling peeled and missing, an ottoman with a suspicious “water stain” across the entire top surface. Again, we came for the jacuzzi and it checked that box, but if it wasn’t such a long ride home I wouldn’t have spent the night. "

"Had a great stay!!!"

"This property is beautiful, we loved sitting at the water around the fire all morning. When the sun comes up right across the water above the trees it is amazing. The train that goes across the water to the right isn’t too loud. The cottage was clean and cozy the only downside was that I couldn’t figure out how to work the fireplace. "