We are a family of 6. Kids 14, 9, 7, 3.
The location is fantastic. Easy walk to the edge one way, time square the other, Empire state building, Grand Central and even central park and intrepid were inside 35 mins.
The rooms were ok. On the smaller side but that's expected but I can't say they were spotless. Also, one of taps in one room was leaking, not a huge deal but the constant run of water was annoying for the first night. We had 2 rooms and despite calling 1 week prior to ensure we were next to each other, when we arrived no one had read the notes the agent left on the booking. Again, not a huge deal but with 2 kids in each room, lugging bags around was a pain. On the second night we managed to move the room with the tap issue so we were all on the same floor. Back to the rooms, the floors weren't 100% clean with dust and debris from the previous visitors. Again, nothing too bad but enough to think they hadn't done a great job.
Would I book again?? probably not if I could find another hotel in a similar location. It wasn't bad but was just ok.
I must say though, the staff were great.