Chilmark Fulling Mill Brook Preserve Hotels

"Very clean house, very family friendly, loved the games closet and proximity to both sides of the island. Would love to stay here again if we have the opportunity. "

"Excellent trip, no surprises exactly what I hoped for."

"Amazing space, modern, clear communication, lots of amenities, large backdoor area"

"Beautiful space. Clean, modern. All amenities. Ample rooms and the location was breathtaking. We absolutely loved the outdoor shower! The location is also perfect for all of the vineyard. We easily accessed Oak Bluffs, Aquinnah, Edgartown, etc. No more than 15 min from anywhere. The host was the cherry on top, she was helpful pre-stay and super responsive throughout our stay. You could tell she takes cares about your stay and it makes you want to take care of it all the more, and I hope we were great guests! Will be back! "

"Had such a relaxing time at Martha’s Vineyard. The property was just as described. We slept comfortably and felt so relaxed on this property. Communication with the host was beyond expectations. Having access to the free car, was truly a huge perk. Will absolutely stay again. "

"Great all around!Recommend highly.Great for people and dog friends.Hosts are communicative, friendly and sweet neighbors."

"A Menemsha treasure! We were delighted with the old fashioned vacation house feel. It was perfect for our visit with our dog "

"Ronnie was a great host, enjoyed our time in Chillmark, she has a beautiful gallery as well, recommend staying with her, we will be back !"

"This is a home that - at one time - was absolutely stunning. The architecture and floor plan are ideal for a family vacation home UpIsland on MV. Unfortunately, the house has been poorly maintained, which significantly detracted from what could have been an exceptional stay.While I appreciate a rustic, lived-in feel, basic cleanliness and functionality should be non-negotiable. The area rugs were visibly dirty and clearly have not been cleaned in quite some time. The furniture showed extensive staining, the lamp above the kitchen table was moldy. The sliding doors were difficult to operate properly, and the screen doors had holes that let in insects.Personal belongings were scattered throughout every room and filled most closets, leaving little storage space for guests. The lack of any welcome information or house manual left us guessing about basic procedures like trash and recycling pickup, appliance operation, and check-out requirements.Most concerning were the unannounced visits from service workers. While property maintenance is important, guests should be notified in advance when workers will be on-site. We had an uncomfortable situation when the pool maintenance person arrived while one of our party was using the outdoor shower area.The bones of this property are truly wonderful, and with proper attention to cleanliness, maintenance, and guest communication, it could easily be a five-star rental. Currently it falls short of VRBO standards despite the premium price."