We enjoyed our 3 day stay at this 2nd floor apartment. It was me and my sister (50’s), and our dad who’s 85. The steps inside to the apartment are steep- they are likely original to the house which is a 2-story Victorian style converted into 2 apartments. I say this to warn anyone traveling with someone with mobility issues- this would not be the house for you. My dad did okay though- we’d go out for the entire day, so he only had to navigate them down and up once. :-) The house location is great- easily walkable to downtown, even for dad (he just kept it slow with his cane). There was a bit of street noise on weekday mornings from trucks waiting in the Shelter Island ferry line which runs along the street in front of the house; it went quickly though. We encountered an issue at checkin and the owner came over to address it immediately. The couch & beds were very comfortable. The kitchen stools/chairs get a fair rating because some of the seat springs are broken and they sunk in. Lots of linens and towels were provided, and there was a pack’n’play we saw in a closet for little ones. We didn’t cook while there so we can’t comment on kitchen equipment. The house also has a few beach chairs for use which was great. Overall it is a clean, renovated apartment in a great close location to downtown, and we’d stay there again.