Independent Monticello Hotels

Blue Door Cottages

10/10 Excellent

"Very kind and welcoming people, and the place is amazing for the price!"

The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!

10/10 Excellent

"Everything was outstanding, the hospitality was amazing"

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

10/10 Excellent

"clean and comfortable and if you workout they have a fullsize gym so perfect stay"

Lake Shafer Country Cottage with Magnificent View

6/10 Okay

"Meeting the owner in person to Acces keys was a challenge for us with timing and traffic. We felt bad for arriving later than planned. When we arrived we found the master bedroom sheets had hair and particles on them. Even though we arrived late at night the owner came right over to fix the issue and replaced the sheets. The view, patio and sand beach are amazing! Steep set of stairs to get down to beach totally not a problem for us but be mindful if someone has mobility restrictions. Additionally the ability to rent kayaks was very nice and convenient. If you are a beginner kayaker probably not the best. To enter the water you go down a ladder into the water where there is a small standing pad to load into the kayak. As a shorter person and high water levels I was not high enough above the kayak to get stability to load therefore had to get creative and hung off the ladder. The mornings were super quiet and peaceful, calm water not a lot of river traffic. Great for kayaking. Afternoon river turned into a party vibe, lots of music. There was a house down river that played music into the evening till about midnight but we did not mind the style was good and a variety. Having a fire on the sand beach was an excellent way to enjoy the sunset evening stars. There were a few spiders/bugs, we chopped it up to being an older cottage hard to seal to keep them out. Great dog friendly, our dog enjoyed the long weekend. She is trained to kayak with us and wears a life vest."

Dockside Lake Resort

6/10 Okay

"Loved how close it was. Loved how friendly and prompt the staff was (we had difficulties with our door code). Didn’t love the smell in the room. Smelled like mildew. Didn’t like that our room was NOTHING like advertised. There was no BEDROOM. It was a studio. The parking was less than ideal for units 8/9/10/11 (angled and made it difficult for anyone leaving the property). Loved the kitchenette in the room. Didn’t like the broken bathroom window (wouldn’t open) and the lack of exhaust fan in the bathroom. Also- mold on the bathroom ceiling in multiple spots. Okay for one night, but will take my chances at another hotel/motel/cabin- accommodation next time. Also- didn’t use the pool- open 10-10. Checkout was simple. No staff at the office… I don’t think ever. Texting, phone calls, and the app are the communication preferences. Also super thin walls. We rented room 9 and family rented 10. You could hear through the walls! Room 11 wasn’t being OVERLY loud, but they could be heard in room 10. And I don’t know if animals are allowed, but someone absolutely had their dog there!!"

Lake-Level Retreat w Hot Tub, Picture Windows & 65” TV for Ultimate Relaxation

10/10 Excellent

"We had a wonderful stay! The view is great, hot tub was fun to relax in, and it was very clean. It is great to be able to see lake views from inside and out.We look forward to coming back again!"

Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer

10/10 Excellent

"Nice house right on the river with beautiful views! We enjoyed staying here. The beds and couches were very comfortable and there’s plenty of space in all the rooms. My kids had fun fishing right off the dock, and my son actually saw a deer crossing the river. I also like that it’s close to restaurants, stores and Indiana Beach Amusement Park. We would definitely stay here again."

Waterfront Monticello Home w/ Fire Pit & Deck!

10/10 Excellent

"Hosts were incredibly helpful. Beautiful property!"

Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!

10/10 Excellent

"The room’s was cleaned and the host was very nice and friendly I enjoyed the lake view"

Room 1

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Top Monticello Hotel Reviews

Blue Door Cottages

The Lake House Everyone Wants w/two decks, great amenities & optional Pontoon!

Best Western Plus Brandywine Inn & Suites

Lake Shafer Country Cottage with Magnificent View

Dockside Lake Resort

Lake-Level Retreat w Hot Tub, Picture Windows & 65” TV for Ultimate Relaxation

Lake Freeman house w/boat dock... Minutes from Indiana Beach/Lake Shafer

Waterfront Monticello Home w/ Fire Pit & Deck!

Lakefront Cottage w/ Deck Near Indiana Beach!

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Independent Monticello hotels

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Top Monticello Hotel Reviews

Blue Door Cottages

Explore a world of travel with Expedia