Search Vacation Homes in Old Lyme

"This fabulous house, a block from downtown Mystic, worked well for our family group of six adults! The house is charming, with lovely art (at least one signed by the owner, if I’m not mistaken), great landscaping, and fresh cut flowers, books, and games. The kitchen was great for cooking a few meals, and we also grilled in the backyard. Also nice to walk to many restaurants. Comfy beds, nice linens, plenty of towels. Also loved the porch! The owners responded quickly when we had questions....

"Very nice place. Would definitely stay there again (actually this our second stay at the property). Clean, well equipped and the pictures are accurate."

"Pretty gingerbread cottage, well appointed. Lovely area, 2 min walk to the beach. Owners super helpful. Overall beautiful, serene, highly recommmend."

"Property was as listed. Access to residence was simple. Right off the highway and close to Mystic center. Will stay here again"

"We were in the area for a visit to local college, and we splurged on an overnight. So glad we did! Spotlessly clean, beautifully restored historical property right in the heart of a neighborhood and in walking distance to downtown. Comfortable beds, art supplies, games, and a well-appointed kitchen. Our daughter didn’t choose the college, but we will be back just to stay here again! Thank you for a truly special property."

"Great stay, convenient location, very charming house with everything we needed."

"The location was amazing and the accommodations were great! Big yard and so many thoughtful ammenities"

"Great Experience...."

"We fell in love with Mystic and are already planning on our trip back to the area! And we LOVED our cute coastal cottage! Deborah was so attentive and we were floored by the way our rental house was presented. It was clean and very comfortable. The historical, nautical feel was so fun for our family spring break getaway. There were comfortable beds for all 6 of us. When we arrived we found a fresh apple pie for us, a fresh daffodil centerpiece, and chocolates by all our beds. The house had...

"We absolutely loved the Dollhouse. My husband and I ‘eloped’ in Mystic with an intimate group and this was the perfect place to stay. The house was the perfect size for us and the location is right in walking distance of downtown. Kerri was an amazing host as well (the best I’ve experienced so far!)."

"This was my second go round staying at this property. My family and I enjoyed it the first time. More so the second time with the upgrades. Being familiar with the area was a great help. This time we went in the lake and enjoyed ourselves. We are looking forward to returning back again. Thank you Raymond for letting us stay at your property. Richard and Joanne"

"Our group of four friends in our 50s loved our stay here. Heather was a responsive, welcoming, flexible host who left us a card, bottle of wine and a prepped wood pile in the fire pit. The decor was tasteful and beautiful, clean and modern. The mattresses were firm, which we liked. We made use of the comfortable couch on the deck as well as the gas fireplace in the living room. The location is lovely and we had a short, 5-minute walk to the beach. Birders would enjoy the tremendous diversity of...

"Loved the place, one recommendation is suggest using Mystic address vs Groton address."

"This was our first stay in this beautiful house, but we will be back! The layout of the home was perfect for our family get together. There is plenty of room and the huge dining table was a big plus for our group. The location is great. It’s in a quiet area of Mystic and yet, within walking distance of downtown. The check in process was easy and communication with the host outstanding. It was a 5 star plus stay and I highly recommend this house."

"Got away for a girls weekend and this was perfect. It was close to wineries, and a short Uber away to Greenport. The house was comfortable, clean, and private with enough space for all 8 of us. The outside was also beautiful- right on the water. Highly recommend!!"

"Myself and 7 friends stayed for a night to celebrate a girls weekend in Mystic and we couldn’t have asked for a more perfect place. Hope was so communicative the entire time and got back to me quickly if I had a question. We loved that it was only a 7 min drive from Downtown Mystic. Everything was clean. The house its self is super cool with the stained glass windows throughout. I wish we stayed in a warmer month so that we could’ve enjoyed the beautiful deck that was there. Just we’ll just...

"This property had everything we needed. Location was great, walking distance to everything downtown. Property had all the amenities we needed as a family."

"Well stocked, very comfortable home with lots of amenities. Great neighborhood as well for walks/runs. We enjoyed our stay and will definitely stay again next time we have a need to be in the area. Highly recommended."

"It was truly a wonderful vacation!!! Jacinta was amazing!! The house was cozy and warm. Loved coming "home" everyday after being a tourist. So close to everything the family wanted to do and see. Jacinta also gave amazing tips of things that weren't on our bucket list but was happy to add. Would stay again in a heartbeat!!"

"Great"

"We loved this property. It’s open floor plan made it a great gathering place. Great location, clean and comfortable. Highly recommend"

"This cottage is so adorable and just a short walk to the beach and a local convenience store. This makes it easy to park the car and just walk to get coffee and such. We stayed in October so not much open this time of year, but we were in the area for a family wedding so not much time to hang out anyway. This was the first time I've rented on Vrbo, so I wasn't sure what to expect as have read a lot about obnoxious owners with tons of rules, but Brett is super-chill with only a couple of things...

"Always a very nice time staying at this property. The sunset on the beach was amazing. Convenient to all area restaurants, wineries, breweries and Matchbook Distilling. "