We recently stayed at this property (2 adults, 2 kids, 1 dog) and loved it. It felt like a relative's beach/lake house that had been in the family for a few generations. Some great modern upgrades within a home with some history. Would recommend and absolutely see coming back again next year.
Pros:
1) About a 15 minute walk outside of Rockaway. We loved walking the beach into town for a coffee every morning. Was great being just outside of the day-visitor activity.
2) The wraparound deck. It gives you both a lake and ocean view (Dining table is lakeside, Hot tub and deck chairs are ocean side). Also feels modern with composite material. (No wood splinters!)
3) Kitchen applicances, hot tub, and grill are all pretty modern. (guessing under 5 years old). Kitchen well stocked with things needed to cook - all you need to bring is food.
4) Off street parking. House is up a hill. I lot of homes in the neighborhood has parking on the street/alley so this was nice.
Cons:
1) TV and living room are facing the ocean. This means the screen glare is massive under the sun goes down. It impacted out kids once, but for the most part we didn't need the tv so was very minor for us.
2) The outside of the house has a lot of metal corrosion. This mattered as some of the door handles and propane grill tanks are beginning to fail.
3) Washer and Dryer are old. They get the job done, however; you might need to run the dryer twice. (About 50/50 for us)
Overall: 9/10!