It was not incorrectly listed. Noyac is a hamlet in Sag Harbor and has a 11963 zip code. It’s mailing address and deed are part of Sag Harbor. This person needs to do his homework before accusing us again of falsehood. This renter deceived us from the start as booking for 2 which can be confirmed on the VRBO website and then arriving with multiple couples for a big birthday bash the following day. When confronted with this and them getting caught for deception, they started verbally attacking us and the house. We have incredibly cruel text that he sent us calling us despicable people, yet we never met him and always responded in kind. This is a most dishonest and conniving person.

I have already documented this three times and just sent pictures as well as the rental contract which they signed. These renters left our house in a deplorable condition with filth and food everywhere. In one of the bedrooms alone, they left a galloon bottle of water open which went all over the rug causing us to rent a blower to dry the wall to wall rug and padding. It is still damp. I did not charge them for all the breakage, dishes, wine glasses and a CD shelf player that they left out in the rain. Please, please refer to all the documentation I have supplied to three previous Homeaway Security people. We never told them they did not have to clean the house but in fact told them (as is documented in their signed contract) that I just sent to Security that they had to leave the house in the same condition they received it or they would be charged a Exit Cleaning Fee. We only told them they did not have to wash the sheets. Olga asked us if there was a cleaning fee and we told her YES if the house was not returned in the same condition it was received by them. Please, Please look at the tons of documentation I have supplied to you over the last week. We have NEVER received a negative complaint in 7 years of renting our house thru Homeaway. Our house was professionally cleaned prior to their taking charge of it. It took us TWO DAYS to put it back in order after they left. The grease on the kitchen countertops alone took the cleaners a whole bottle of Dawn (full strength) to clean. They only started to complain when I told them I had to charge them a cleaning fee. Up till then and at the time they left, they sent us an email stating what a lovely house we had and how beautiful it was decorated and what a great time they had. This email is all documented and attached in the three responses I gave to Security over the last week. This is not fair to us as we bend over backwards to accommodate our renters as you will see stated in our prior 5 Star Reviews. Please do not allow them to discredit us in this way. It is unfair as we are honest people and provide a clean, lovely house for people to rent. Thank you for your consideration and just help us to put this terrible situation behind us. If you need any other info, PLEASE refer to the prior documentation we have sent and attachments with pictures taken upon them leaving the house and their rental agreement we have sent. We do not deserve the review that they posted. Thank you. Laurie & Richard McGee