I booked this rental for me and my husband's anniversary trip to Yellow Springs. We probably would have had a fine stay, but we found the bed terribly uncomfortable. We tossed and turned all night and kept waking through the night sore and having difficulty getting back to sleep. Not being able to sleep through the night on a supposed relaxing trip was really disappointing. We ended up not staying for our second night, opting to go home to our own bed instead. And, the futon was an option, but only if we wanted to be sleeping directly on top of each other all night.
Another issue I had were the hard water stains. I'm from the country, and had hard water growing up. It leaves deposits and can smell odd. However, with proper maintenance, can be managed. There seems to have been no effort to remove any of the hard water deposits anywhere. The shower handles and caddy are covered, as is the entire inside of the dishwasher. It is just a bit off-putting.
The host was kind and easy to communicate with. Hopefully some of these issues can be resolved so others can stay comfortably near the fun, quirky town of Yellow Springs.