Hudson FASNY Museum of Firefighting Hotels

"The low rating is due to the worst night sleep I've had in a long time. Most of this property's issues are beyond the control of management. But the walls are paper thin, the windows are very old and not double or triple glazed thus every single sound penetrates and you feel as though you're sleeping outside. There is a train that comes through regularly all night long with train whistles. There is a church bell that tolls on the hour (I heard it at 3am, 4am, 5am, 6am and 7am)! There are various sirens of ambulances and fire trucks, and heavy trucks like garbage trucks. It is just such a loud neighborhood and not sure what can be done because the house is historic. Two things would have improved the stay: blackout curtains (there are only flimsy horizontal blinds that do not darken the room whatsoever. Also, put a mirror in one of the bedrooms (we were in the 2 bed suite) so that one can do hair and makeup while the other is showering. I will say that the accommodation was spotless, it's got a nice vibe aesthetically, the water and snacks a nice touch and check in went smoothly. Communication was good as well. But, unfortunately, I can't give it a higher rating because it was just such a terrible sleep. "

"Main hotel building, including the bar and restaurant, were pleasant. Didn't eat, but the drinks were on point. Walls in the annex building, where my "half pint" room was located, are incredibly thin. Although there's a quiet policy (after 11pm as I recall), guests in adjacent rooms were up all night talking and their voices came right through the walls. It was as if we were part of their conversations. Not a minute of sleep. Hotel offered a comp though, some attempt made. "

"Sheets were dirty- hotel seems to house homeless "

"new hotel, people complaining about creeky floors, but guess what its a converted factory with original wood floors. ONLY ISSUE, baths are NOT open and charging the resort fee. poor form"

"We had a beautiful room with a comfortable artificial fireplace. Thehotel is perfectly situated in the middle of Warren Street surrounded by galleries, shops and restaurants."

"Nice clean spot in the best possible location for food and shopping. We could hear the restaurant nextdoor very clearly while sitting in the common area, but our room on the other side of the hall was quiet. Room was spacious with a spacious bathroom. Shower pressure left something to be desired. "

"Everything was great, would definitely stay here again. Very cozy, clean and quiet. Great amenities. Short walk to the main drag (Warren)."

"Very pet friendly. Such a cool place. Fun room layout. Convenient to strolling in town to hit excellent restaurants. Definitely will be back. "

"Hot tub was great. We stayed out of pool season."