Old Lyme Selden Neck State Park Hotels

"Overall our stay was a positive experience. It definitely is pretty outdated and common areas could use some maintenance (like peeling wallpaper and stained ceiling tiles) but everything was very clean, and I have high standards for cleanliness. The pool was very clean as well. We used it twice during our stay. Its a heated pool but don't expect bath water warm. Its just not freezing. Our room was nothing special but the bed was very comfortable. The bathroom is tiny but the photos arent misleading. The shower gets warm not hot. Not an issue for me but for others it might be. My only real complaint about the room was that we had planned to use the pullout couch for our daughter to sleep on but the mattress was extremely old, stained, and ripped. We assumed there would be sheets and a pillow for it but we had to call the desk and ask for it. Would have made more sense for the staff to ask at check in if we needed those things if they arent provided. Once we recieved those items we realized the sheet was much too big for that mattress. Kinda seemed like the pullout couch was not an actual option for a guest to use and we would not book that room again for that reason. The hotel is also right next to the highway and the windows are not well insulated so you hear the traffic at all times of day. Not an issue for my family but worth mentioning in a review. All the staff we had interactions with were super friendly. Would recommend as a budget friendly option in the area!"

"The check-in process was very easy. The passcode to get into the cabin was provided about two hours before check-in. Upon arrival, the cabin was very clean and stocked with necessities. I was able to keep in contact with the staff via text and they were very prompt to respond."

"THIS WAS A QUICK GETAWAY FOR ME AND MY WIFE. THE PROPERTY IS GREAT. WE COOKED IN BOTH NIGHTS. EVERYTHING WAS AVAILABLE. WE BOTH LEFT FEELING WE WILL BE BACK AND NEED TO FIND A HOUSE LIKE THIS FOR OURSELVES. WOULD RECOMMEND TO ANYONE NEEDING A WEEKEND OR WEEK AWAY. "

"Needed a one night stay - worked fine"

"As always this home never disappoints! There’s enough space for everyone to have family time but also have alone time. The game room is fantastic!"

"Our stay was perfect in every way! The house is amazing. Not only is it a beautiful large house, the hosts have thought about everything their guests could want. The kitchen had everything you need to cook incredible meals (and we did). It was a lovely space to spend time with friends, while having plenty of space to step away to work in private. The house was extremely clean and beautifully decorated. The hosts could not have been nicer and made sure to check in to be sure we didn’t have any questions during our visit. This is absolutely one of the best homes we have visited and we would love to return!"

"Room was spacious and very comfortable. Description did not match the room. There was a tub but it wasn’t a jacuzzi and there is no radiant heat in the bathroom as stated. There's actually no heat in the bathroom at all. Way overpriced. This room is not worth $600 per night. I wouldn't go back."

"Great long weekend! The cottage is comfy, quaint, and included everything we wanted and needed to enjoy a couples retreat over the Valentine’s Day weekend. The owner was responsive and kind. We will be booking again, can’t wait to see the property in the summer right on the river as it was amazing during this winter stay. "

"Our host was very nice. The cottage was nicely decorated for Christmas, however, there was a terrible smell in the house that hinted of vermin. I also saw a mice dropping on a chair. We cut our stay short. The kitchen had stronger odor. It was disappointing because the house itself reminded me of the movie The Holiday."