Highgate Independent Sugarloaf Key hotels

"Stayed there for 10 days March 1 -10, 2026. Just an awesome place. Staff, food, pool, location. One of the best things is they have a shuttle that runs until 10:30 pm to take tou down to old town and pick you up. I rented a car and dint even use it much because the shuttle is the way to go. Parking is expensive downtown. I would highly recommend this hotel. Just an amazing experience. "

"Beautiful beach and very helpful staff!"

"The pool loungers were awful. Room was clean."

"Fantastic resort. I really don’t want to post how awesome it is because I don’t want it to be hard to book. "

"We enjoyed the multiple pools with friends. Our room was amazing and had a beautiful view of the water with lounge chairs and hammocks for relaxing!"

"Great area and nice outdoor area to hang out at."

"we stayed in a standard room but it was lovely and close to the pools with a wonderful side patio. pretty property. would definitely stay there again."

"The pool was just like the pictures. They had decorated well for the closest holiday. The staff was very fun! No outside food or drinks at the pool were allowed, which was a little disappointing because my group was planning on purchasing outside drinks from a grocery store to save money. The shuttle from the hotel was very helpful. The hotel was very close to the airport, which was convenient. The condition of the room was great!"

"The property shares a fence with the airport. At check in we were greeted by idling jets and jet fuel in air. The noise level inside the unit and on our veranda was much more tolerable. The property was exceptional and we enjoyed our stay despite the occasional plane taking off."