Based on proximity to the beach and convenience, this location was a dream. The sheets seemed to be clean but the overall condition of the home was filthy. They ask you to maintain a "shoeless household" but the floors were so gross. I don't know if the carpets have ever been vacuumed and the kids were sneezing all weekend. The dining and coffee tables had so many filth layers that even our clorox wipes didn't seem to make it clean. Layers and layers of dust and dirt on shelves, shutters, and window sills. We visit Catalina every year and understand that a beach home is never immaculate, however this was unacceptable. Looking back I should have refused keys until the property was cleaned to a more acceptable standard. We paid top dollar and I hope this encourages management/home owner to uphold a more proper standards for their guests.