Edgartown Mytoi Garden Hotels

"Lovely little home on Chappy. We had everything we needed during our stay. Comfortable, spotless and updated home. Away from all the crowds in Edgartown yet a quick little ferry ride over that you can walk on without needing to worry about parking downtown. Owner was very responsive throughout our stay, even offering to let us stay as long as needed past checkout time due to snow and a late boat! Would absolutely stay again. "

"Very cozy comfortable hotel!!"

"Cannot wait to return 😊"

"The sunsets were spectacular! Felt like home. Very comfortable and had everything we needed. Just an FYI: Some of the window hardware was stripped and difficult closing the windows especially the right one where the round table is. The sliding door near the kitchen would also get stuck and hard to close. The fire detector was missing in the living/kitchen area."

"Room was spotless and staff were amazing!"

"What a gorgeous location, my family and I had a wonderful time on Chappy, will definitely be back!"

"Highly recommend. We loved the tranquility. This was a perfect escape from noise. The beautiful bird calls over morning coffee on the porch, and daily visits from a doe and her fawn were special. We hiked several miles on the beautiful trails. Van's Butterfly Cottage is cozy, immaculate, and has a calming decor. Van is a very attentive and superb host. Thank you, Van! "

"Great family friendly home with lots of living space and activities such as tennis, pickle ball, ping pong, and games all on the property. My family of 10, inclusive of 4 grandchildren had an awesome time."

"The house is well maintained. Check-in was very easy. The house is located in the woods in a bit of a labyrinth of small roads. The kitchen facilities were great. Craig had recently purchased a new set of pots and pans that were in excellent condition. Craig was extremely helpful and welcoming. Everything functioned well from the stove to the bathroom. "