Search Cottages in Monticello

"The property owner and staff were personable, attentive and responsive. Our cottage was perfect - plenty of room and the amenities were comfortable. We have stayed here in the past, and will continue to stay here on our visits to Monticello. Highly recommended."

"This house was so cute. The owner thought of everything, from linens and towels to little extras you may forget. The deck was amazing and takes you diwn to the water. The decor is nice and not dated or overly complex. The place is quiet and peaceful...just what we needed. The owner was responsive and all that was advertised was true. Enjoyed our stay very much."

"Bob and Jayne are the best hosts ever. Awesome cabin right on the lake. Great deck overhanging the water with a lot of sitting area. Fire pit for evening enjoyment lake side. I’d recommend this cabin to anyone and we will be returning 👍"

"My family of seven had a great time on this property. The house was beautiful and the backyard and pier were wonderful. We loved our stay! Our host was also incredibly responsive and kind. Every detail was thoughtfully considered."

"Very clean house with an awesome deck and dock. Close to boat rental."

"Only stayed one night but would love to come back again and stay longer. Comfortable, open concept space, perfect amount of amenities for a short or longer stay. We really enjoyed the decor and history of the building."

"House was an amazing location, very clean, great amenities, property manager was responsive, I have no negative feedback and this is def my preferred location to come back to visit!"

"We loved this property! Quaintness was awesome - property was friendly and cozy! Right by the water, close to In Beach. Staff at Paradise Cove were more than helpful and went above and beyond - we have already booked for next year!"

"Overall as expected"

"I enjoyed staying at the eagles nest. Cozy, clean, peaceful. Thank you :)"

"Cute little cabins"

"We started with cabin 2 and it was completely unsafe to stay in. The screen door and entry door neither one would close properly, the bathroom toilet was about to fall through the floor, the mattress was stained horribly and very broken down and the air conditioner was not plugged in and when they tried to plug it into a double prong instead of a three prong extension cord that was frayed as well is totally unsafe. The kitchen light was flashing. The smoke detector still had the tab that looked...

"The location of the cabin to the lake was awesome, each cabin had a patio with view of the lake as well as a shared patio with chairs and fire pit at the lakes edge."

"We had a great time!! Loved the house! The neighbors was great! Played euchre on the deck! Nice lighting outside to see the cards! Loved the shower!! Great cute property! We will be back again!!"

"The property owner and staff were personable, attentive and responsive. Our cottage was perfect - plenty of room and the amenities were comfortable. We have stayed here in the past, and will continue to stay here on our visits to Monticello. Highly recommended."

"Exceptional, cozy and private. We really enjoyed are stay."

"Cute, clean cabin on the lake. Perfect for a short stay if spending the day at Indiana Beach!"