Search Vacation Homes in Old Forge

"We stayed for one night and enjoyed our stay. Very clean, cozy, and warm. Plenty of games available to pass the time. Owner was very easy to communicate with and answered any questions right away! Would stay again if in the area."

"The space was clean, brand new construction and was very welcoming. Host was very communicative and resolved any issues we encountered. Overall would recommend and will stay here again."

"John was awesome! He took care of everything and responded quickly!"

"Was easy to find and very comfortable rooms beautiful scenery "

"We had a great time and the hosts were wonderful "

"Nice relaxing place for two"

"If you're looking for a unique, fun and very relaxing place to stay, you've found it! We stayed in the main cabin in September 2025 and were thrilled with its rustic charm. We enjoyed so many activities both on the island and in the surrounding area which felt like a nostalgic step back in time. We really loved using the included boat to get to and from the island, for fishing, and to position ourselves for perfect sunsets on the lake. We also loved using the kayaks. The private dock was ideal...

"We have a very nice stay in Croghan as we were working in the area for a few days. The host was great to communicate with and was very helpful. It was a very small and safe town with a couple of places to eat. We weren't concerned about leaving equipment in the back of the truck at night. The lodgings were clean and basic. Overall a very nice stay, thank you! "

"Everything was amazing and Scott and Ina were very accommodating. We will be back again!!"

"Had a great weekend getaway, great views from the hot tub. "

"Everything me and my wife were looking for on our honeymoon!"