Nantucket Old Gaol Hotels

"Former sea captains house in historic Nantucket has beautiful rooms, is very clean and the staff and current owner are very accomodating. Rooms are spacious, bed is comfortable and shower has plenty of pressure and hot water. Would highly recommend a stay here."

"Very clean and hosts provided great communication"

"yes it was good"

"The house is very attractive inside and out. It is comfortable, modern and full of windows. We did not give it 5 stars because it is starting to show a few signs of usage but it is still very clean. It's in a perfect location to walk to downtown, and has 2 public parks nearby. Perfect for 2 people....sleep sofa is good for children, or a younger adult. We had our small dog and there were no problems with anything related to a behaved pet being there. There is one parking spot by the side and front doors. The area is very quite and relaxing. Yard is pretty, private enough and is as picture shows. Overall a nice rental!"

"Sean is the man! Great place to stay."

"Room was very clean and staff was helpful from beginning to end. Stayed in room 304 which was a top floor room. Second day in there was a bunch of stink bugs falling from ceiling onto the bed . I know they are harmless. Just annoying little creatures "

"I’ve stayed at this hotel twice. Beautiful place, great location. The only issue I could someone having in there are no elevators. I stayed on the third floor this time and while I didn’t mind carrying my bag, someone a little older (+60) may have an issue. Staff are willing to help if necessary."

"Make sure you see the picture of the actual room before you book, Our room was incredibly small, was advertised as a standard size guest room , it was a large closet , for one guest it was manageable, two way to small ."

"Extremely helpful and kind staff. It was a wonderful place to stay for the weekend."