Search Vacation Homes in Sayville

"Our stay was very nice."

"My girlfriend and I had an absolutely wonderful time visiting Cherry Grove/Fire Island for the first time, and the Grove Hotel was a big reason why. Our room was immaculate, it appeared to have been recently renovated/updated, with plenty of room for 2 and a nice mini-balcony for viewing the wildlife at the pool and the bar. 😎 Cherry Grove is a tiny hamlet, so location can't be a real issue no matter where you stay, but the hotel is literally steps away from the clubs, restaurants, shops, market, ferry, water taxi, etc. And it has its own great club (the Ice Palace). But what really sets this hotel apart is the staff. Just so incredibly friendly and laid back and super helpful anytime we needed anything - like checking our luggage when we got there early, texting us when our room was ready while we enjoyed a cocktail by the pool, providing extra pool towels on request, room cleaning on demand. Even the cleaning staff was friendly and engaging. It's hard to think of any way they can improve the experience, so I'll get very picky and suggest they could expand the pool hours (closing the pool at 8pm or even 6pm on some days was an epic tragedy 😫). Nonetheless, if we ever get back to Cherry Grove we know where to stay."

"It was very nice and clean a great staff had a nice time"

"Cleanliness is very good. Staffs are friendly. Shuttle bus is convenient to go to Stony brook University. Transportation to other places is difficult. "

"Great location. "

"We arrived early and Janet at the front desk was so accommodating she was able to get us signed in and our room was very comfortable "

"👍👍👍"

"Needs live tables"

"Room was very clean. Breakfast was very good,I had buffet each day. Customer service was excellent very pleasant stay."