This is a quaint, old building with small rooms, outdated climate control & plumbing, makeshift bedding, age stains, and awkward layouts, (e.g. public deck with seating has a window right into our bedroom as well as another.)
The parlor is charming and offers complimentary coffee and brandy - although the carafe was empty when I wanted a nip. Soft drinks are complimentary from a fridge on the upstairs deck. Those service aspects - as well as the breakfast - were outstanding. And if the stay were priced at $150/night, I would be on here raving about this BnB as a gem in St. Augustine with thumbs up and 5-stars everywhere.
However, at $450/night, this is atrocious, and I feel ripped off. The water pressure is like a Greek youth hostel, the bedroom window has no blackout blinds, so the room was light all thru the night by the deck lighting. Climate control is jury rigged - there's a thermostat on the wall for cooling, but if you want heating, there's a wall unit mounted in the back wall of the closet, so you have to figure out how to turn on in the dark, and then you have to leave the closet door open so the heat blows into the room. You have to monitor it manually since there is no auto on/off, and if left alone, you could spend the night in a sauna. These might all be idiosyncratic in a cheaper setting, but for $450/night, I expect more. A lot more.