Sugarloaf Key Historic Hotel

"Beautiful place to stay, and they run a shuttle over to Duvall Street, so it's easy to get around. Pool was clean and really nice..."

"Really nice hotel while you’re in the keys!"

"Operating on an “if it’s not broke don’t fix it” mentality. Very outdated and small bathrooms. Mold on shower curtain. Loud AC. Pool was nice great music restaurant had good food and service. It was fine for a quick 2 night stay but looking at comparable locations of other properties and price I would stay elsewhere next time."

"Love this hotel! Friendly and helpful staff, rooms are nice and the balcony with ocean view was spectacular. Although the property is older, the cleanliness and friendly staff more than make up for the age. The restaurant on property is excellent, and the location can’t be beat. We will be back!"

"The pool was enjoyable and relaxing. "

"Nice property..."

"The entire staff were cordial and so helpful. We would absolutely stay here again. The shuttle service was an excellent amenity."

"My husband and I woke up with bed bug bites and the air conditioner was not functioning properly the last night of our visit. This was not the room that was shown on your website - we did not have a partial island view. The hallway was open to the beach all day and all night. We were surprised when we arrived that we would have to pay a $65 charge per day for each of us. That was not listed in the description on your website. We would never stay at this hotel again."

"Everything was as pictured on web site. Loved the pool. Would definitely go back again"