East Hampton Three Mile Harbor Hotels

"This home has great potential, though a few details still need attention. There were no shampoo or extra garbage bags when we arrived, but the host quickly arranged to have them brought over, which we appreciated. The washer and dryer weren’t fully operational, and the two extra bedrooms didn’t have nightstand lamps. In the master, one of the two lamps was missing a bulb.The outdoor patio and pool area looked lovely, though we didn’t use them since it was too cold during our stay. Overall, the house could be wonderful with a few touches to make it feel warmer and more inviting. The ceiling lights are very bright white, and without softer lamps, the lighting felt a bit harsh. Also, the thermostat was set to 61F when we arrived in the fall, which made the house quite chilly at first.That said, the host was very kind and responsive, and I’m confident they’ll address these small issues to make future stays even better."

"Pool was great once it heated up. Owner quick to respond to communication"

" Perfect Sag Harbor Getaway!We had such a wonderful stay at this beautiful new home in Sag Harbor! From the moment we arrived, everything felt fresh, spotless, and so thoughtfully designed. Each of the four bedrooms having its own bathroom was a huge plus for our group, and the house had absolutely everything we needed. We loved the two spacious decks — one on each side of the house — perfect for morning coffee or evening cocktails. The backyard offered great privacy, and we spent hours lounging by the sparkling pool and relaxing in the hammock. With plenty of parking and peaceful surroundings, it truly felt like our own private retreat. We can’t wait to come back!"

"Absolutely wonderful experience at this property! We visited from Manhattan with family and couldn’t have asked for a better stay. The house was spotless and private, the pool was gorgeous, and the location was perfect — close enough to the towns when we wanted to explore, but peaceful when we wanted to relax. Rick was incredibly helpful and quick to respond. Highly recommend!"

"Excellent experience and Anthony was a wonderful host. His house served us well for a long weekend. We were in town for a wedding so it was a perfect mid way point between the Montauk wedding location and Sag Harbor brunch the next day."

"We had a wonderful stay at this property! The home was beautiful and spacious. The pool was great. The host was very responsive and helpful! The house was stocked with everything we needed and was kept very clean. This was a perfect choice to stay with our family and 15 month old. We appreciated the amenities they had for young children. We hope to stay again! "

"Lots to do, easy access and host is responsive. Great time had by all!"

"Beautiful property, but no restaurant open for lunch, no pool service, no one to answer calls at front desk. Constant marketing notices."

"This house is very comfortable for a family retreat. Also well stocked with towels, beach towels and anything you might need in a kitchen. Lots of seating outdoors and the pool was great. "