Pros- We enjoyed the quiet of the house and backyard. We were traveling with pets and it was nice to have a place that allowed us to have them. The rental management company was helpful, friendly and quick to respond to messages.
Cons - Living room couch was uncomfortable as the leather cushions slipped easily and it was hard to sit on. Bed was VERY soft and upon removing sheets at check out could see the mattress pad was dirty. Bathroom shower curtain was dirty and no bar of soap was available. The kitchen pots/pans were old and stained and there was only a 2inch kitchen sponge to clean them with. I didn't feel like the host maintained/cleaned efficiently enough. The comfort items we are used to in a place were lacking.
Not a pro or con, but also to be aware the bedrooms are upstairs and the stairs are very steep. I know this is common for the older homes, but for some it might be a concern.
Overall, it was a good place but I'm not sure it was a good fit for us.