Water Island LGBT Welcoming Hotel

"great property"

"Had studio overlooking the bay. Beautiful room, comfortable bed. M/W didn't work and range difficult to use so maid brought hot plate. Did deal with a couple large cockroaches but guess that's common to the area. Front desk very helpful with info about the area and things to do. Restaurant had delicious food but no a/c, very slow service one night, other was fine. Cash only was a bit inconvenient but there is ATM on site. Resort is remote so you will pay extra in cab fare and some taxis won't drive there to pick up. No groceries nearby (store closed down). Steep walk down to scenic beach ($7/person to use Magens Beach). $6 taxi ride back to resort was worth avoiding the climb back. Plan to pay for taxis to go see anything unless you rent a car since resort is isolated from shopping and other restaurants. But is in ideal location for Magens Bay and has newer modeled rooms (due to 2017 hurricane)"

"Have to taxi everywhere. Lots of seagrass"

"My problem was that my bathroom shower drain had hair in it and the floors wasn’t clean. Sticky and slippery. Also if there’s no towels and wash cloths on the rack where they belong look under neath the sink in the cabinet. The room was awesome awesome though. "

"The beach, the staff and service was great!!! "

"Super friendly staff. "

"This property was so fun. It is on a big hill so hard to walk up but the view is beautiful. The room was very nice. Would definitely stay there again"

"I didn't like that TV has no good working channels and rooms doesn't have a microwave "

"Food was delicious, excellent menu to choose from. Great, friendly staff. A very nice resort with a perfect laid-back attitude."