Butler Buck Mountain Hotels

"Had a pretty nice buffet breakfast and overall a beautiful hotel. The elevators do run really slow."

"I had to listen to security then the police, try to throw someone out of the room across from me for two hours. Restaurant staff is not the most attentive and they do not seem happy to be there. Rooms are worn and torn."

"The rooms were clean and the service was friendly and helpful. The location was central and there were subway stations close by."

"Clean room. Great staff. "

"Great location "

"The rooms were incredibly small, although very clean. The mattress and pillows were uncomfortably soft. We did, however, appreciate the blackout curtains and TV programs. The hotel staff was all so kind, but if you lingered in the lobby for more than a minute, a staff member would approach you to sell you a hotel discount on a future stay. The Wi-Fi was extremely spotty and unreliable. I was disappointed to have gone 2/3 nights without a solid connection. The location of this hotel was quite good - 5-minute walk to Penn Station and close to some food places and souvenir shops. Not to mention, it neighbours a fabulous coffee was shop, Vanilla Gorilla, which we regularly frequented. The outskirt of the building was relatively quiet overall, compared to other NYC stays."

"This property was perfect for us. It was small, but we didn't spend a lot of time in the room. It was walking distance to Times Square and many other sites. We would definitely stay here again."

"Restauranr"

"This hotel is in a state of disrepair. In my opinion, they barely meet the basic standards of a hotel. The owner of this establishment should seriously consider a complete renovation, as it has an excellent location. On a side note, some of the advertised amenities are simply not available!"