Indianapolis Hamilton Proper Park Hotels

"Great property. Staff was solid for check-in. Rooms very nice. One elevator was inop but the other one worked in a timely fashion. Bathroom was partially updated but tub and tile a bit dated. Minor complaints. Overall excellent location, hotel and staff. Would definitely book again!"

"I wouldn’t recommend this property. Our room was dirty, many items were broken in the room. The exercise room was locked and unavailable, breakfast was instant coffee and waffles. Not good."

"Very clean and inviting. Fun location with great dining options "

"In all fairness, they are doing a full remodel. It looks like they just started though. Maybe it’s been in the planning stages for some time so they let the property go a bit, not sure. My room smelled like BO, wallpaper was peeling everywhere, bathroom fixtures broken (but working). Air conditioning unit facade falling off the wall, carpet worn out and dirty looking. That said, maybe in a few months it will look like a new place due to the serious pending remodel. I stayed at the end of March 2026. I cannot complain about the continental breakfast! It was pretty decent!"

"Clean home and very easy to contact host that responded promptly. Very nicely located in the Fishers area near a lot to do. "

"Every thing was clean and presented as described. The host James was available and responded quickly. We absolutely loved our stay. We were able to access and park on the garage. The neighborhood was really nice and quiet."

"Great stay. Clean. Modern. Amazing food around hotel. Vibes. Yes. And more yes. "

"Very responsive and amenities were great!"

"Super nice, they told us they have curtesy coffee and when we got there they said no, friendly staff, rooms are nice bit small and dark..!!! "