Caldwell Hotel with Pool

"Friendly staff, comfortable rooms."

"Rooms are a bit out dated "

"bar was fine"

"I don’t know about the other reviews, but you can turn the heat off in your room, and the window ac works just fine. "

"Our air conditioner was broken for a couple days and it was 80 degrees. We called to get it fixed, and three hours later nobody came. We had to call again then finally someone came and opened the window. The AC was broken the whole time though (besides the first day)."

"I didn't like the auto 20% gratuity at the restaurant, but the food was good if not over priced. Cleaning staff was great. "

"Not that clean and the front desk staff where pretty unfriendly."

"Everything was great! "

"Great property close to Times Square. Rooms are small with no fridge or microwave, but this is an old, historic, well-kept property that we would definitely return to. Get to know "Bobby the Doorman", he's been there for 47 years!! Breakfast at Friedman's was great."