Search Cottages in Sag Harbor

"Continently located, beautiful room with ocean views! Loved it"

"I love this hotel off season. We were actually the only ones staying there I believe. The rooms are so clean and modern. The bath soap, lotion and shampoo were the highest quality. The sheets Frette and the towels Matouk! I love that it is across the street from the ocean & across the street from town. My only small complaint was that the housekeeper never came to change towels, fix bed & empty trash. We were there 2 nights & fortunately neat & hung our towls after use."

"Parking was easy. Bed mattress terrible. Tired room and furnishings. Basic supplies. "

"We had a wonderful time. Enjoyed the location, the food, the pool, and my wife loved her massage. "

"It is a lovely hotel."

"So clean! Loved the location."

"Clean hotel , comfortable room, beautiful views, quiet place, EZ access to the beach. Coming back for summer"

"Great little nook, right off the highway. :)"

"Everything is always excellent here. The rooms are always well stocked without being overstocked; you have the ability for physical and downloadable media to watch and enjoy; parking passes are always supplied without having to ask for them; wake up calls are attentive and they don't forget them; and, I'm writing this review as a person who has been to Montauk Manor on 11 different occasions. I love what they have done with their exercise room and the changes they made to their pool and sauna area - and believe you me, I used every amenity available to me. Also, the restaurant is phenomenal - I actually went to it when it first opened back up, and it continues to not disappoint! If you are looking for a One-Stop shop, a place where you can just sit and be, a place where you can be within walking or short driving or biking distance to montauk, the beach, the lighthouse or a short excursion to wineries and such, this is the place for you. As a matter of fact, I am already planning my 13th visit!"