Tingler Island Holiday Rentals

"Based on reviews,Im not sure what people expect from a $99 a night in the keys.. Its a low cost Motel not the Hilton. The good.. private and large size rooms, office gentleman made check in quick and easy. Outdoor is well kept and nice looking. The bad.. obviously a run down place where low or none maintenance it's done, not well kept cleaning wise but it looks worse than what it is because it's all old and not well maintained But again...$99 night in the keys..."

"Nice, pleasant smaller hotel. Clean. Staff was friendly and helpful. Pool was nice as was the hot tub. Amenities were nice. Beach a little disappointing but useable. We had a great experience here. "

"The room was actually nice, but this is not a resort dont let that fool you. The buffet breakfast is a joke it might have yogurt it might not, best thing is they have microwavable Jimmy dean sausage biscuits awesome. Also they say this magnificent buffet is only for two people and you you need to pay $11.95 for additional participants. You might as well cruise down the street to mickie dees. Also watch out for the marina Karen. Hey if youre looking for a base of operations in the middle keys this probably isn't the worst option out there. Back to the marina Karen we saw the cops there 3 times for her dire needs in the 4 days we had the privilege of staying."

"Room was clean, no balcony or view tho…nice pool area with connect 4, bags and some extra activities. Friendly staff. Have to pay for parking. "

"Room was clean and spacious! Property was beautiful with a dock to the bay, coffee bar, and complimentary kayaks. We saw a manatee while relaxing on the dock! Will definitely stay again if we return to Marathon. "

"Awesome vibe stunning sunset views, quiet but everything you need is at your finger tips. Convenience walking distance away and boat rental "

"Parking was safe and easy."

"They dont strive to serve. Our room had a sliding bathroom door that did not lock or remain closed. It took them 3 days to fix it. The last day, the entire floor smelled fish. They sprayed copious amounts of air freshener but it didnt help. Overall, its a nice place with great views and amenities but it doesnt justify the price tag. I'm sure a few years ago it did, but generally you just get the feeling that no one is trying to deliver a great guest experience."

"We enjoyed our visit here. The best part was the lounge chairs - as they had arm rests. The pool was enjoyable. The rooms were sufficient - although we could hear someone snoring from another room. The bathroom was remodeled and "