Key West Nancy Forrester's Secret Garden Hotels

"This room faced a parking lot BUT it was close to the shore pool and that was a bonus. Be prepared for the daily amenity fee of $65 plus tax for each day of the stay, it adds up quickly."

"The room I paid $1,250 for one night lacked privacy because the window blinds were poorly installed and sloppy. The bathroom had an old bathtub, and the faucets were nearly falling apart. The TV was extremely outdated. I’m very disappointed. I’ve visited Key West many times, and this is by far the worst hotel I’ve ever stayed in."

"Pool and pool bar were great! Our only problems were a noisy a/c unit and worn carpet in hallway on 2 nd floor. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Room was comfortable. We were able to walk to restaurants and bars and museums. We would stay there again. "

"My room was very small but overall a very nice place to stay. Premises were clean and staff was awesome. "

"Breakfast menu was lacking, not enough seating. Maid service was poor. Room was fine and conveniently located "

"The carpet is old and stained. The pool is a good time and the staff is very friendly. The cleaning staff is a bit aggressive and could leave more than 1 towel per person but all and all a nice place. "

"Loved the property on Simonton Street. Close to Duval and everywhere else for convenience!"

"Location cannot be beat, close to the action on Duval but secluded enough to feel like your own oasis. Pool and Hot Tub are awesome."

"The room was clean ,but the sheets and pillowcases were worn out and threadbare . The bathroom was tiny , the sink and toilet was clean , but the shower was gross ! It was black mold in it , we spent 2 nights there , and we didn’t shower, I got some water dripping on the floor , I took a washcloth and wiped it up, the cloth turned black! They included breakfast in the price , but it was the the tiniest breakfast we ever had, so the next morning we went out and got a good breakfast . The elevator didn’t work when we came ,so we had to use the steep staircase and carry our suitcases up to the second floor , if you would fall there ,you could breake a lot ! The lady at the front desk was not very friendly, nor accommodating , she was not helpful. When we came down in the morning there was no good morning , she didn’t say a word unless someone spoke to her. "