Caye Caulker Caye Caulker Forest Reserve Hotels

"This was a perfect place for our family. We had the benefit of the quiet side of the island with the amenities of a resort atmosphere while easily taking a ferry to visit the south side for restaurants and night life. "

"The hotel was absolutely beautiful, very clean, everything new and with nice touches. Friendly staff and the best swimming pool (for lap swimming) that I've found in the region. Highly recommend."

"Great location and amenities, views can't be beat! The bikes were a little dilapidated, but sufficed to get us around easily. Helpful notes on arrival and the help with departure arrangements including a direct shuttle to the ferry dock couldn't be better. A!"

"We booked this property expecting an “entire home,” but the layout and access were very different from what we anticipated from the listing. The rental is actually the upper level of a multi-level structure, and the main entrance requires walking along a narrow side pathway and climbing exterior stairs to reach the living area. This made the property very difficult to access and did not work for a member of our group with mobility limitations.Future guests should also be aware that the lower level of the building is a separate apartment that may be rented to other guests at the same time. Because of this setup, the property does not feel like a standalone private home, and there may be other people staying in the same structure during your stay.Because of the access and layout issues, we were unable to stay for our planned trip and had to leave earlier than expected. We were very disappointed that these details were not clearly disclosed in the listing, as they significantly affected our ability to use the property as planned.Guests expecting a fully private house or easy access should review the setup very carefully before booking.The neighbors who live next door with the bar also manage the property and are lovely. We enjoyed them!"

"The room my family and I were in was perfect. Ist floor, Ocean View, next to pool for the kids. It was great. The bar and a restaurant seconds away. We enjoyed ourselves. "

"We loved our stay at Magic Island, its a great hotel if you want to have a relaxing holiday but still able to access the south side of the island at ease. The rooms have a beautiful view of the ocean and have everything you need. The staff really make this hotel, they are amazing and create such a special experience for guests!"

"5 star staff, Yvan, Candy, and Jamie are wonderful. They make you feel like your family."

"The room was clean and had many of the basics. The property description is a little misleading as there is no beach on the property. There is a seawall and an amazing pier, but do not expect a beach or a good place to swim. The water is very murky and full of sargassum, and unfortunately a fair amount of trash. Some photos are clearly old because neither unit has a deck as seen in some the photos. There is no ocean view, but the trees are lovely. Speaking of trees, this was a big issue. The wind blows constantly on the island and at least one tree hits the metal roof hard and repeatedly, making a very loud banging sound all night. It was difficult to sleep during the entire stay with a tree limb smashing the roof all night."

"It was a very nice property. It had a few issues in thebathroom. Very poor lighting and floor got wet from theshower. Everyone that I dealt with concerning the propertywas very helpful."