Overall I'd give this 4 out of 5, we've been here before about 5 years ago and had a lovely time, it's much the same here.
Just assume that everything else is great in terms of comfort and cleanliness, apart from the following:
- The downstairs shower really could do with having the mastic replaced as it's mouldly now (and the showerhead needs a really thorough descale). It's not terrible, but when everything else is so good, it stands out.
- There were a few really big, thick cobwebs around the beams and in the fireplace, which is a bit disconcerting as it makes you think the rest of the cleaning might not be up to snuff - which doesn't seem to be the case, but it does make you question it.
- The upstairs bathroom floor tiles have been cracked since we'd last been, I would have expected these to be fixed by now.
- The heating schedule needs to be amended, it's so cold upstairs overnight - it's a obviously a old cottage with single glazing, but that heating schedule could be set to compensate. It's set to 18 during the day and 15 overnight, I fettled it a bit (and reset it at the end of our stay) which did help, but you really need to have it set about 20 at night, which in reality will be about 17 upstairs before it kicks in).
I'd definitely go back, so none of the above would put me off.