St. John Whistling Cay Hotels

"Loved beautiful view. Everything close by"

"Dwight was very helpful and the house was beautiful!"

"This place is a hidden gem. While we were ready to escape reality for a few days we didn’t have access to wifi/internet despite multiple requests so this made it challenging to be able to plan where to go or how to get there. "

"Wonderful property and location. Easy access to Cruz Bay and north shore beaches. One of the best views I’ve had on island!"

"Mayling’s property is brand new, completely redone. We stayed on the ground unit. The tile is beautiful and has great bathrooms. The kitchen is nice..we did not cook but the space is comfortable. Smart TVs in all three rooms. This is a nice unit that feels new. Mayling also left us plenty of towels, paper towels, toilet paper, even beach chairs that we did not use, as we had our own. Warning, it is hard to find and the driveway is very steep, but she gave us excellent directions and any property on the mountain on Centerline road will not be easy to enter. We live in St Thomas half the time so very used to the driving on St John. It is likely too far for most to walk to Cruz Bay or more likely home, but definitely less than a mile. "

"We absolutely adored our stay at the Peter Bay Gatehouse, Penthouse! It was one of the best places we’ve ever had the pleasure of staying in. The location was simply stunning, with easy access to some of the world’s most beautiful beaches. The view from the penthouse was breathtaking, and we never wanted to leave because of its breathtaking beauty. We’re already looking forward to our next stay here in the future!"

"If you’re staying at the villas or treehouses, just know they’re doing construction (as of Feb 2025), which can be annoying if you plan to stay at your villa between 8:30 AM and 4 PM. Don’t get me wrong this surroundings and areas beautiful and the service is mostly great. Will definitely come again to give it a second chance! "