Islamorada Theater of the Sea Hotels

"Great stay, better than I even expected from the pictures. Quiet, quaint little place right on the water. The edge is actually a dock, but it looks like it’s right on its own, private, wide beach! The internet was good - I had a half day of doing Zoom work calls and had no problems. It’s quiet, the bed and pillows were comfortable, and the coffee in the room was strong and good. Close to a couple restaurants within walking distance, one of which was dockside with outdoor seating that was so relaxing (Island Grill). Definitely would stay again. "

"Yes and yespool parking view"

"The breakfast was excellent with a nice variety and made to order. The room was spacious and the bed was comfortable. I really like the spacious bathroom. The only negative was the refrigerator kept freezing our food & beverages. "

"beautiful resort, simple and clean room with fantastic amenities and views! Lots of variety with beaches, pool and food options! "

"Great little seaside place."

"Have stayed at Anglers Reef many times and this is by far our family's favorite house we have rented. Great 3 bedroom layout and well appointed with everything you need. Loved watching the sunrise from the deck. The communication with the owner (Lyndsey) was great and she made sure we had everything we needed. Highly recommended. "

"Very clean and updated rooms. Outside bar area and food awesome. Very friendly staff. You would drive past OV if just looked at it from the A1A. Take the time and go around back. "

"Our host thought of everything; communication was great- early checkin was provided as well. The location near sandbar, Publix, The Village shops, bait shop, many restaurants was awesome! The condo was spotless, towels provided, paddleboards, games, books etc. The view of this particular condo was worth the upgrade. Lattes were a hit as well! All good things-"

"Host is responsive and informative. Resort is spectacular... Pristine grounds. Beautiful pool and beach is perfect for sunrise and sunset. Lots of kayaks and paddle boards to use. Home is clean and well stocked. This was our third time at anglers reef and it never disapoints"