Independent San Carlos Island hotels

"Very clean and comfortable. Busy breakfast area, but well stocked for the crowd. "

"The golf course offers a great view, but the biggest bonus is the complimentary shuttle and boat ride to a private island beach with free lounge chairs. Hyatt also provides free coolers to borrow, as there are no food or drink options on the beach, and complimentary towels. The lazy river is also an amazing feature, and the pool area is great. "

"Staff was wonderful, very friendly and attentive. Room was in very poor condition — needs a refurbish desperately, particularly the bathroom. "

"Hotel was beautiful. Highly recommend. "

"Clean room great local"

"Bar area fun and inviting. Building could use some updating but considering Hurricanes were hard on the area it’s understandable. Bed not real comfy. Staff very friendly and helpful. "

"Bathroom was very dated - not worth $800 per night. "

"Would not recommend. For the positive, we did have good customer service when I had to challenge the bill because the previous guest's bar bill was put on our room. Also, the view was nice, looking at the harbor. Noise from the bridge is loud when on the balcony but you cannot hear it when the door is closed. Several issues were noted with broken or poorly maintained areas in the room and elevators. Worst was the Tarpon House restaurant - we walked out after more than an hour with no service beyond drinks, and that was after hunting down a host who was MIA for more than 10 minutes. We watched it happen over and over as more people arrived and stood in the doorway with no assistance. "

"We had a balcony directly facing the beach. It was gorgeous and the hotel was lovely, but they are still having some construction so we were woken up by the sound of a drill at 8 am. "