Sanibel Sanibel Island Lighthouse Hotels

"I booked a suite which wasn't cheap, only to find out it's above the office and the farthest room from the beach. The property was understaffed with one person working the Tiki Bar and one bartender in the restaurant resulting in long wait times to get a drink or food. The beach is very nice, the pool area just ok. "

"We had a wonderful stay overall. It would have been even better if greater attention had been given to environmental sustainability—for example, providing recycling options in the rooms and avoiding plastic straws, cups, and cutlery at the pool restaurant. Sanibel Island is a beautiful and fragile environment that deserves to be protected."

"My husband and I stayed here for the first time in February of 2026. It met all of our expectations! The room was clean, pool area was well kept, and it was a short walk to the beach. We also liked the fact that they provided beach chairs/umbrellas. We were also very fortunate to meet the property owner, Denise, while we were there and she was extremely kind and helpful. We are ready to book it again!"

"It’s all about the location, the staff and facility. Margaritaville has it all."

"The suite was spotless upon arrival, and was very comfortable for the two of us. The renovations are very attractive - flooring, kitchenette, bathroom ... all are perfect. We appreciated the great mattresses, both in the main bedroom and in the bunk bed: nice and firm, giving excellent back support. We also were very grateful for a terrific AC system that kept the suite at an optimal temperature. The host is responsive and considerate, replying swiftly to the one or two questions we had. The suite is located just a short walk from Lighthouse Beach, which is fantastic. We collected a wide variety of shells, watched pelicans, ospreys, and dolphins fishing, and saw a splendid sunset. "

"I love the Anchor Inn on Sanibel. I will return. The Inn is cozy, comfortable, quiet, and perfectly located so I could get anywhere easily."

"Unfortunately we had the unpleasant experience of staying at the Captiva Tower. So, no the pool was not enjoyable because of the sewer smell coming from the parking lot. I spoke to management and they did apologize for the lack of service, amenities and cleanliness of Captiva Tower and did refund some of our money. So, staff are great at the front desk."

"The room was good condition, we enjoyed the pickleball courts. The food was pricey and just so so quality. "

"The host was very accommodating . The location is great and very clean. Access to the beach is right out the door. We had a great experience ."